Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 8 · Symposium · 732 words

What Makes a Life Meaningful?

A philosopher, a novelist and a retired stonemason each give a short answer to one of the oldest questions there is.

When Leo Tolstoy was about fifty, wealthy, famous and in good health, he was overcome by a question he could not answer: what will come of everything I do? He described the crisis in A Confession, and the question has echoed ever since. We asked three contributors to take it up. We also asked them to keep in mind a distinction that is easily blurred: a meaningful life is not necessarily a happy one, nor is it simply a morally good one.

Dr Helen Achterberg, philosopher, Glasgow. The most helpful answer I know comes from the American philosopher Susan Wolf, who argues that meaning arises when subjective attraction meets objective attractiveness. Both halves matter. Imagine someone entirely absorbed in counting the blades of grass on a lawn. He may be passionate, even joyful, but few of us would call his life meaningful, because the activity is not worth that kind of devotion. Now imagine a doctor who does valuable work but feels nothing for it, going through the motions for the salary. Her work does good, yet she is alienated from it; something is missing there too. Meaning, on this view, requires loving something that is genuinely worth loving.

The obvious objection is: who decides what is worth loving? I don't think we need an official list drawn up by experts. It is enough that the things in question can be appreciated from more than one person's point of view: friendships, understanding, making something beautiful, helping others to flourish. These are not arbitrary tastes. They are things that most people, on reflection, can see the point of, even when they do not share them.

Isobel Carraway, novelist, Norwich. As a novelist, I am professionally suspicious of plots. In fiction, everything that happens points towards an ending that makes sense of it. Life does not work like that, and I think many of us suffer from expecting it to. Albert Camus called the clash between our hunger for meaning and the silence of the universe "the absurd". His emblem was Sisyphus, condemned by the gods to roll a boulder up a hill for ever, only to watch it roll down again. The task is the very picture of futility. Yet Camus ends his essay with the sentence "One must imagine Sisyphus happy."

I used to read that as a kind of heroic defiance. Now I read it more quietly. Sisyphus is happy, I think, because he stops waiting for the story to be finished. He notices the texture of the stone and the changing light on the hill. Meaning is not a prize handed out at the end; it is a quality of attention. We are not characters in search of a final chapter, and there is a certain freedom in accepting that.

Gordon Pike, retired stonemason, York. I spent thirty-eight years in a cathedral stoneyard, so you'll forgive me for being practical. The men who began the great cathedrals knew they would never see them finished. Some took two hundred years or more. They carved faces and flowers high up on the roof where no one on the ground would ever see them clearly, and they carved them just as carefully as the work at eye level. There's an old poem about builders working on "each minute and unseen part", because "the Gods see everywhere". I'm not religious, but I know exactly what the poet meant.

I don't think about meaning much, to be honest. I think about doing a thing properly. When I replaced a weathered carving, I was joining a conversation with a mason who'd died six centuries before, and handing it on to someone not yet born. That's not grandiose. It's just a long job with a lot of people on it. If Professor Camus wants a happier picture than his boulder, he could do worse than a scaffold on a cold morning, with a flask of tea and a chisel that's been properly sharpened.

Three answers, then, which converge more than they first appear to. None locates meaning in a single feeling, and none treats it as the same thing as pleasure. Each points outwards: towards things worth caring about, towards the world noticed closely, towards work that will outlast the worker. Tolstoy, for what it is worth, found his own answer in the faith of the ordinary working people around him, which might have pleased Mr Pike.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
overcome/ˌəʊvəˈkʌm/so strongly affected by a feeling that you cannot control it
blurred/blɜːd/made less clear, so two things seem to mix together
absorbed/əbˈzɔːbd/so interested in something that you notice nothing else
alienated/ˈeɪliəneɪtɪd/feeling separate from something, as if it is not really yours
arbitrary/ˈɑːbɪtrəri/chosen by chance or personal wish, not for a good reason
futility/fjuːˈtɪləti/the state of being completely useless, with no result
defiance/dɪˈfaɪəns/refusing to obey or give in to a power
stoneyard/ˈstəʊnjɑːd/a working area where stone is cut and carved
weathered/ˈweðəd/damaged and worn by wind, rain and sun over many years
grandiose/ˈɡrændiəʊs/trying to seem much bigger and more important than it is
scaffold/ˈskæfəʊld/a frame of metal poles and boards that builders stand on
converge/kənˈvɜːdʒ/come together towards the same point
outlast/ˌaʊtˈlɑːst/continue to exist for longer than someone or something
flourish/ˈflʌrɪʃ/grow and develop well; live a full, healthy life

What Makes a Life Meaningful?: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.