Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 9 · Feature · 792 words

The Power of Thought Experiments

A feature visits a philosophy seminar and a physics classroom to ask how imaginary experiments, from Galileo's falling stones to the trolley problem, can teach us anything real.

On a wet Tuesday afternoon in Edinburgh, twelve undergraduates are deciding whether to push a stranger off a bridge. Nobody, I should add, is in any danger. The stranger, the bridge and the runaway tram below exist only in the imagination, and the seminar's tutor, Dr Marcus Lindqvist, is conducting what may be the oldest experiment in the world: one that needs no laboratory at all.

Lindqvist: So the tram will kill five people unless it is stopped, and the only way to stop it is to push this large man into its path. Would you push him? Hamish: No. Absolutely not. Lindqvist: But earlier, when you could save the five by pulling a lever that sent the tram onto a side track, where it would kill one person, you said yes. Hamish: I know. The numbers are the same. I just can't explain why it feels completely different. Lindqvist: Good. Hold on to that feeling. It's the most interesting thing in the room.

The original "trolley problem" was devised by the British philosopher Philippa Foot in 1967, and the version with the bridge was added later by the American philosopher Judith Jarvis Thomson. Half a century on, it has become something of a cultural fixture, discussed by engineers designing self-driving cars as well as by philosophers. Its endurance raises a puzzle of its own. How can we learn anything from an experiment whose results are simply our own reactions to a story we have made up?

The question is not confined to ethics. Some of the most important advances in physics began as flights of fancy. Galileo challenged the long-held view, inherited from Aristotle, that heavy objects fall faster than light ones. His argument needed no tower. Suppose, he said, we tie a heavy stone to a light one. If light things fall more slowly, the light stone should act as a drag and the pair should fall more slowly than the heavy stone alone. But the pair is heavier than the heavy stone, so it should fall faster. The theory contradicts itself; the only consistent answer is that, apart from the effects of air, all bodies fall at the same rate. Einstein, too, recalled that at the age of sixteen he had imagined chasing a beam of light, a reverie that eventually led him towards special relativity.

"Children are natural experimenters of this kind," says Priya Nair, who teaches physics at a sixth-form college in Leicester. She uses Galileo's stones with every new class. "There's a moment when they realise they've proved something without touching anything, and you can see them sit up. It's a lovely bit of intellectual magic." She is careful, though, to add the other half of the lesson: that Galileo's conclusion still had to be tested against the world, and that a thought experiment is only as good as the assumptions it smuggles in.

That warning lies at the heart of the most serious criticism of the method. The philosopher Daniel Dennett called such scenarios "intuition pumps", devices for producing a strong reaction, and he urged readers to "turn the knobs": change one detail at a time and see whether the intuition survives. Often it does not. Psychologists have found that people's answers to trolley problems can shift with small changes in wording, or even with the order in which cases are presented. If our reactions are so malleable, critics ask, why treat them as evidence about morality at all?

Lindqvist takes the objection seriously but thinks it proves less than it seems. "A thought experiment works rather like a laboratory experiment," he tells me afterwards over a cup of coffee. "You isolate one variable and hold the others fixed. In the trolley cases, the number of lives stays the same; what changes is whether you use someone's body as a means. If people's reactions differ, that tells us something about the principles we actually hold, even if we can't yet state them." He compares it to Galileo: neither experiment adds new data, but both bring hidden tensions in what we already believe to the surface.

There is a further, gentler defence. Thought experiments are, in the end, a kind of story, and stories have always been one of the ways human beings test ideas before risking them in reality. Erwin Schrödinger introduced his famous cat in 1935 not as a serious proposal but as a reductio, intended to show how strange one interpretation of quantum theory became when applied to everyday objects. The cat was never in a box; the argument was. As the Edinburgh seminar breaks up, Hamish is still frowning. "I came in thinking I knew what I believed," he says. It is, Lindqvist observes, exactly the right predicament in which to leave.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
fixture/ˈfɪkstʃə/something that has been in a place for a long time and is expected to stay
endurance/ɪnˈdjʊərəns/the ability to last for a long time
flights of fancy/ˌflaɪts əv ˈfænsi/imaginative ideas that are not based on reality
drag/dræɡ/something that slows down movement
contradicts/ˌkɒntrəˈdɪkts/says the opposite of something; here, says two things that cannot both be true
reverie/ˈrevəri/a pleasant daydream
intellectual/ˌɪntəˈlektʃuəl/connected with thinking and understanding
smuggles in/ˌsmʌɡəlz ˈɪn/brings something in secretly, without anyone noticing
malleable/ˈmæliəbəl/easy to change or shape
tensions/ˈtenʃənz/ideas that pull against each other and do not fit together
reductio/rɪˈdʌktiəʊ/an argument that shows a view is wrong by showing it leads to something absurd
predicament/prɪˈdɪkəmənt/a difficult situation that is hard to get out of
devised/dɪˈvaɪzd/invented or planned something new
conducting/kənˈdʌktɪŋ/organising and carrying out

The Power of Thought Experiments: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.