Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 11 · Essay · 795 words

The Unreliable Narrator

A critical essay on narrators whose accounts we learn to distrust, from Wayne C. Booth's definition to Ishiguro's butler, and on why such narrators can bring us closer to the truth.

Every story told in the first person comes with an unwritten contract. The narrator says, in effect, 'This is what happened', and the reader, having no other witness to consult, agrees to believe it. Most of the time the contract holds. Yet some of the most arresting novels of the last two centuries are built on its quiet breach: they hand us a guide whose account we gradually learn to distrust, and they make that distrust the very source of their meaning.

The phrase 'unreliable narrator' was coined by the American critic Wayne C. Booth in The Rhetoric of Fiction, published in 1961. Booth called a narrator reliable when he or she speaks for, or acts in accordance with, the norms of the work – the values of what he called the 'implied author' – and unreliable when he or she does not. The definition is more subtle than it first appears. Unreliability, for Booth, was not simply a matter of lying. A narrator may be perfectly sincere and still mislead us, because the values through which he sees the world are not the values the book invites us to share.

It helps to distinguish between several kinds of unreliability. There is the narrator who is naive: Mark Twain's Huckleberry Finn reports the world with a boy's honesty, and much of the novel's power lies in the gap between what Huck describes and what the adult reader understands. There is the narrator who is self-deceived, perhaps the richest variety of all. And there is the rarer narrator who deliberately withholds information, concealing a crucial fact until the final chapters and thereby forcing us to reread everything that came before.

The finest modern example of self-deception is Stevens, the butler who narrates Kazuo Ishiguro's The Remains of the Day (1989). Stevens never tells an outright lie. He is, if anything, scrupulous about accuracy. What he cannot do is admit what his own story reveals: that his loyalty to his employer was misplaced, and that his devotion to professional 'dignity' cost him the chance of personal happiness. Ishiguro's achievement is to let us see, through the narrator's carefully composed sentences, everything the narrator himself refuses to look at. We read Stevens rather as one reads a letter from a proud friend, attending less to what is said than to what is so conspicuously left out.

How does a reader detect unreliability at all, when the narrator is the only source? The answer is that texts leave clues. A narrator may contradict himself, or protest too much; other characters may react in ways that do not fit his version of events; his diction may grow stiff and formal precisely when the subject becomes painful. Experienced readers learn to notice these discrepancies, much as a good listener notices when a friend's cheerful tone does not quite match the look in her eyes. In this sense the unreliable narrator does not weaken the bond between book and reader so much as make it more active. We are no longer passive recipients of a story; we become, in a small way, its detectives.

Some critics have argued that the label is now applied too freely. If all narrators are partial, as in some sense they must be, then every narrator is unreliable and the term loses its use. There is force in this objection. Memory is selective, and no one tells a story without shaping it. But the distinction Booth drew still seems worth keeping. There is a difference between the ordinary partiality of any human witness and a narrative deliberately designed so that the reader will see past its teller. The first is a condition of storytelling; the second is a technique.

Why should such a technique matter beyond the seminar room? Perhaps because it trains a habit of mind that everyday life demands. We are surrounded by first-person accounts – memoirs, testimonies, advertisements, posts – each of which presents itself as the plain truth. The unreliable narrator teaches us, gently and without cynicism, that sincerity and accuracy are not the same thing, and that the way a story is told can tell us as much as the story itself. It also teaches a kind of compassion. Stevens is not a villain; he is a man who has built his life on a mistake and cannot bear to see it. To read him well is to understand how such mistakes are made.

That, finally, is the paradox at the heart of the device. A narrator we cannot trust can lead us closer to the truth than one we can, precisely because he makes us work for it. The contract with the reader is not broken after all. It is simply rewritten, with more of its terms in the small print.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
arresting/əˈrestɪŋ/very striking; catching your attention strongly
breach/briːtʃ/the breaking of an agreement or rule
coined/kɔɪnd/invented and used for the first time (about a word or phrase)
implied author/ɪmˌplaɪd ˈɔːθə/the picture of the writer and their values that a reader builds from the book itself
subtle/ˈsʌtəl/not obvious; delicate and clever in a way that is hard to notice at first
naive/naɪˈiːv/lacking experience of life, so believing and reporting things too simply
self-deceived/ˌself dɪˈsiːvd/believing something untrue about yourself because the truth is too hard to accept
withholds/wɪðˈhəʊldz/keeps back; refuses to give
scrupulous/ˈskruːpjələs/extremely careful to be correct and honest
composed/kəmˈpəʊzd/here: carefully put together; also calm and controlled
conspicuously/kənˈspɪkjuəsli/in a way that is easy to notice
diction/ˈdɪkʃən/the choice and style of words a speaker or writer uses
discrepancies/dɪˈskrepənsiz/differences between things that should be the same
partial/ˈpɑːʃəl/seeing things from one side only; not completely fair
selective/sɪˈlektɪv/choosing some things and leaving out others
cynicism/ˈsɪnɪsɪzəm/the belief that people are always selfish or dishonest
small print/ˌsmɔːl ˈprɪnt/the details of an agreement, often printed small and easy to miss

The Unreliable Narrator: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.