On a bench in a basement laboratory in Glasgow, a row of glass flasks bubbles away under a warm lamp. Inside them, Dr Fiona Leckie and her team are trying to recreate, on a very small scale, conditions that might have existed on Earth some four billion years ago. 'Nobody expects a frog to crawl out,' she says with a smile. 'We're looking for something far humbler: a molecule that makes a copy of itself, even badly.'
Her ambition is modest only in appearance. The question of how life began, how a world of rocks, water and gases gave rise to the first living cells, is among the oldest and most stubborn in science. We know roughly when it happened. The planet formed around 4.5 billion years ago, and the earliest widely accepted traces of life are at least 3.5 billion years old. What we do not know, with any confidence, is how.
The modern search began in earnest in the early 1950s, when a young American chemist, Stanley Miller, working with Harold Urey, filled a sealed apparatus with water and simple gases thought to resemble Earth's early atmosphere, and passed electric sparks through it to imitate lightning. Within a week, the liquid had turned brown, and analysis revealed amino acids, the building blocks of proteins. The result electrified the public. It seemed that life's ingredients could assemble themselves almost effortlessly.
Seventy years on, the mood is more chastened. Scientists now think the early atmosphere was probably rather different from the mixture Miller used, and making a few ingredients turns out to be the easy part. A cell is not a bag of ingredients any more than a cathedral is a heap of stones. It needs a way to store information, a way to copy that information, and a boundary, a membrane, to keep its contents together. The conundrum is that in modern cells these tasks depend on one another. DNA holds the instructions for making proteins, but proteins are needed to copy DNA. Which came first?
One influential answer is the 'RNA world' hypothesis. RNA, a close chemical cousin of DNA, can store genetic information, but certain RNA molecules can also speed up chemical reactions, a job usually done by proteins. Perhaps, the argument runs, early life relied on RNA alone, and DNA and proteins took over their specialised roles later. The idea is elegant, and laboratory work has lent it real support. Critics point out, however, that RNA is fragile and notoriously difficult to make from scratch under realistic conditions. 'It's a beautiful answer to the chicken-and-egg problem,' says Dr Leckie, 'but it may simply move the egg somewhere else.'
Then there is the question of where. Charles Darwin, in a private letter in 1871, wondered about a 'warm little pond' rich in chemicals. His speculation has modern descendants: some researchers favour shallow pools on volcanic land, where repeated drying and wetting could concentrate molecules and encourage them to link up. Others look to the deep ocean, to hydrothermal vents where mineral-rich water seeps from the seabed. There, natural differences in chemistry across thin rocky walls might have provided both energy and a kind of scaffolding for the first metabolism. Each camp has its champions, and the debate is lively rather than acrimonious; most researchers accept that the answer may combine elements of several ideas.
Why does the question matter beyond the laboratory? Partly because it bears on whether life is a cosmic fluke or something the universe produces readily wherever conditions allow. If the steps from chemistry to biology turn out to be fairly natural, then the many planets now known to orbit other stars become far more intriguing. If they required an extraordinary run of luck, we may be rarer than we like to imagine.
It is also, Dr Leckie suggests, a lesson in intellectual patience. 'People sometimes ask whether we'll ever know for certain,' she says. 'Honestly, perhaps not. Nobody filmed it, and the evidence has been cooked, crushed and recycled by billions of years of geology. But we can show which routes are chemically possible, and which are plausible. That's not a failure. That's how you investigate an event that left almost no fingerprints.' She glances at the flasks, still quietly bubbling. 'And every so often,' she adds, 'the chemistry surprises us.'