On a winter evening, tens of thousands of starlings gather above a marsh and begin to move as one: a vast, shifting shape that swells, folds and pours across the sky. There is no leader, no plan, no choreographer. Each bird, as far as researchers can tell, simply responds to a handful of its nearest neighbours. Out of these local reactions comes a spectacle that none of the birds intends and none of them can see whole. It is with this scene that Marcus Ellery opens The Choir Without a Conductor, his ambitious and occasionally exasperating book on emergence.
Emergence is the name scientists and philosophers give to the appearance of patterns or properties at one level that are not present at the level below. A single water molecule is not wet; wetness belongs to vast numbers of them together. A single ant is a creature of startlingly limited abilities, yet a colony can build elaborate nests, find the shortest route to food and regulate its own temperature. A traffic jam can travel backwards down a motorway for miles, although every car in it is moving forwards. In each case, the whole seems to do something that none of its parts does.
Ellery is at his best when describing such examples, and he describes a great many. His chapter on the Game of Life, invented by the mathematician John Conway in 1970, is a small gem. On a grid of squares, each cell lives or dies according to a few simple rules about its neighbours. From this austere beginning, astonishing structures appear: patterns that glide across the grid, patterns that produce others, even patterns that can, in principle, perform any calculation a computer can. Ellery conveys the vertigo of watching complexity arise from almost nothing, and readers with no mathematics will follow him easily.
The book also makes a valuable case against a certain kind of arrogance. In 1972 the physicist Philip Anderson published an essay with the memorable title 'More Is Different', arguing that knowing the laws that govern particles does not allow you simply to work out chemistry, biology or economics. Each level, he suggested, has its own laws, which must be discovered on their own terms. Ellery takes up this argument with enthusiasm, and his conclusion, that reductionism, the habit of explaining things by breaking them into parts, is a powerful tool rather than a complete philosophy, is sensible and well argued.
The trouble begins when Ellery tries to make emergence explain everything. By the final third of the book, it is being invoked to account for consciousness, the rise of cities, the success of pop songs and the behaviour of the stock market, sometimes within a single chapter. Here a distinction he mentions only in passing becomes crucial. Philosophers separate 'weak' emergence, in which the behaviour of the whole is surprising but could, in principle, be worked out from the parts, from 'strong' emergence, in which something genuinely new appears that could never be worked out in this way. The starlings and the traffic jam are clearly examples of weak emergence. Whether anything in nature is strongly emergent is fiercely debated. Ellery slides between the two senses with a nonchalance that a careful reader will find troubling, and the effect is to make bold claims sound more established than they are.
There is, too, a danger in the word itself. To say that a pattern 'emerges' can sound like an explanation when it is really a label for something we have not yet explained. Ellery is aware of the risk, warning, rightly, against using emergence as 'a polite word for magic', yet he does not always heed his own warning. Too often, a chapter ends with the flourish that the phenomenon simply emerges, as though the matter were thereby settled.
None of this makes the book unworthy of attention. Its enthusiasm is infectious, its examples are well chosen and its central insight is both true and important: the world is organised in levels, and understanding one level does not automatically hand you the next. Readers who come away from it looking at a flock of birds, an ant trail or a queue of traffic with fresh eyes will have gained something real. They would simply do well to keep a pencil handy, and to underline, now and again, the word 'how'.