In 1793, hiding from the revolutionary authorities in Paris, the philosopher Condorcet began one of the most sanguine books ever written. His 'Sketch for a Historical Picture of the Progress of the Human Mind' argued that humanity was advancing, by fits and starts but inexorably, towards greater knowledge, freedom and happiness. He did not live to see it published: he died in prison the following year. There is a grim irony in a man composing a hymn to human improvement while the revolution he had supported closed in around him, and critics of the idea of progress have rarely resisted pointing it out. Yet Condorcet's hope was not naive. It was a wager made in full view of the evidence against it.
The idea he gave such memorable form is younger than we tend to assume. For much of recorded history, many cultures pictured time as a cycle of rise and decline, or as a falling away from a lost golden age. The conviction that the future will, on the whole, be better than the past took hold in Europe only in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, carried on the back of the scientific revolution. If knowledge could accumulate, the reasoning ran, then so could its benefits; and if nature could be understood, perhaps society could be improved by the same patient method.
Its modern defenders have something Condorcet lacked: data. Over the past two centuries, average life expectancy across the world has more than doubled; the proportion of people living in extreme poverty has fallen dramatically; literacy, once the privilege of a few, has become the norm in most countries. Such figures are not easily waved away, and those who dismiss them tend to be people for whom a vaccine or a clean water supply has never been a matter of life and death. To deny that anything has improved, the optimists argue, is not sophistication but a failure of gratitude.
The sceptics' reply is not that the figures are false but that they answer the wrong question. Material progress, they point out, is cumulative in a way that moral progress is not. A physicist today knows more than Newton did simply by standing on his shoulders; nobody is born kinder than their grandparents for having inherited their books. Each generation must learn decency afresh, and can squander it in a single decade. The twentieth century, which gave the world antibiotics and, in many countries, universal suffrage, also produced industrialised warfare on an unprecedented scale. Progress in our power to act, on this view, is not progress in the wisdom with which we act, and may even outrun it.
The most haunting image of this doubt belongs to Walter Benjamin, who in 1940, shortly before his death, described a painting by Paul Klee as the 'angel of history'. The angel faces the past, Benjamin wrote, and where we perceive a chain of events, he sees a single catastrophe piling wreckage upon wreckage at his feet. A storm blowing from Paradise has caught his wings and drives him helplessly into the future, to which his back is turned. 'This storm,' Benjamin concluded, 'is what we call progress.'
A third objection, more recent, concerns the bill. Much of what the optimists celebrate was paid for with energy drawn from fossil fuels, and the costs of that bargain – a warming climate, exhausted soils, vanished species – were for a long time left off the ledger. To call the last two centuries progress, the critics say, is rather like praising a household's standard of living without asking how much it has borrowed against the house.
Where does this leave us? Not, I think, with a choice between complacency and despair. Both positions share a hidden assumption: that progress is a law of history, something that either operates or does not, like gravity. Condorcet himself sometimes wrote as though it were. But the more defensible view treats progress less as a fact about the past than as a project for the future – real, measurable in places, and entirely reversible. The gains in health and literacy did not arrive on their own; they were won by people who believed improvement was possible and worked, often against entrenched opposition, to bring it about. The same belief, held without humility, has also justified schemes of breathtaking arrogance.
Perhaps the healthiest attitude is the one Condorcet adopted almost by accident: hope held in the shadow of danger. He did not write his 'Sketch' because the world around him was improving; he wrote it because it plainly was not, and he refused to accept that it must remain so. That is not optimism in the cheerful sense, which assumes the outcome. It is something sterner and more useful – a conviction that the future is underdetermined, and that what we do with it still matters. Progress, in other words, is not an escalator that carries us upwards whether we walk or not. It is a staircase, and somebody has to build each step.