Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 32 · Radio discussion · 738 words

Trust in Institutions

In a radio discussion, three guests debate whether falling trust in public institutions is a crisis, a healthy sign of scrutiny, or something in between.

What follows is an edited transcript from 'The Long View', a weekly discussion programme. The chair, Miriam Hale, was joined by Tobias Wren, a historian of public life; Aileen Kerr, who spent twenty-five years in the civil service; and Rafael Duarte, a data journalist.

Miriam: Surveys in many countries suggest that trust in institutions – parliaments, the press, the courts, big business – is lower than it was a generation ago. Tobias, is this the crisis it is often said to be? Tobias: I'd be wary of the word 'crisis'. For one thing, the golden age of trust is partly a mirage. People trusted institutions in the 1950s partly because they knew so little about them. Deference is not the same as trust; it is trust that has never been tested. Miriam: So the decline is simply people waking up? Tobias: Partly. When you can see how the sausage is made, you lose a little appetite. But I don't want to be glib about it. A society in which nobody believes anything an official says has a serious practical problem, whatever the historical reasons.

Aileen: Can I come in there? I think we often confuse two separate things: trust and trustworthiness. The question isn't simply 'How much do people trust us?' but 'Do we deserve it?' An institution that is trusted more than it deserves is in a dangerous position, because it has no incentive to improve. One that is trusted less than it deserves is wasting good work. The aim isn't more trust. It's trust that is better calibrated. Miriam: How would you calibrate it? Aileen: By making institutions easier to check. Not merely publishing documents – anyone can bury bad news in a forty-page annex – but making it genuinely possible for an outsider to find out whether a promise was kept.

Rafael: I'd push back slightly on the idea that transparency is the cure. In my work I see the opposite effect as well. The more information an organisation releases, the more material there is for someone to take out of context. Total transparency can produce a kind of permanent suspicion: every email becomes a scandal in waiting. Aileen: That's a fair point, but the answer to selective quotation isn't secrecy. Rafael: Agreed. My point is that we've treated transparency as a panacea, and it isn't. What people respond to, a good deal of research suggests, is less the volume of information than whether they feel they were treated fairly – whether a decision was explained, whether their complaint was heard.

Miriam: Rafael, is falling trust the same everywhere? Rafael: Not at all, and that's what the headlines miss. Trust isn't a single reservoir draining at the same rate. In many surveys, people express far more confidence in their own doctor or local school than in 'the health system' or 'education' in the abstract. It's the distant, faceless institution that suffers most. Tobias: Which tells you something. Trust is built locally and lost nationally. People judge the institution they meet on a Tuesday morning very differently from the one they read about. Miriam: Is a degree of distrust actually healthy? Tobias: In a democracy, I'd say essential. Many constitutional arrangements – courts that can overrule ministers, a free press, regular elections – are, in effect, distrust written into law. They exist because nobody should be trusted with unchecked power. Scepticism is part of the design.

Aileen: Scepticism, yes. Cynicism, no. The sceptic says, 'Show me.' The cynic says, 'Don't bother showing me; I already know you're lying.' The first keeps institutions honest. The second lets them off the hook, because if everyone is assumed to be dishonest, the honest official gains nothing by being honest. Miriam: That's a striking claim. Aileen: It's one I watched happen. When I started, a well-run department was proud of its reputation. By the end, some colleagues had given up caring what the public thought, because they felt nothing they did would change it. Cynicism is corrosive in both directions.

Miriam: We're almost out of time. One sentence each: what would rebuild trust? Rafael: Fewer promises, kept more reliably. Overpromising does more damage than any scandal. Aileen: Make it easy to check us, and then let people check. Tobias: Patience. Trust takes years to build and moments to lose, and there is no shortcut – least of all a public relations campaign. Miriam: On that sobering note, thank you all.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
mirage/ˈmɪrɑːʒ/something that seems real but is not
deference/ˈdefərəns/polite respect and a readiness to accept what people in authority say
glib/ɡlɪb/speaking too easily and lightly about something serious
calibrated/ˈkælɪbreɪtɪd/carefully adjusted so that it is exactly right
annex/ˈæneks/an extra section added at the end of a document
take out of context/ˌteɪk aʊt əv ˈkɒntekst/quote words without the surrounding words, so their meaning changes
panacea/ˌpænəˈsiːə/a single solution for every problem
reservoir/ˈrezəvwɑː/a large store of water; here, a store of something
in the abstract/ɪn ði ˈæbstrækt/as a general idea, not a real example
faceless/ˈfeɪsləs/impersonal; with no individual people you can see or know
scepticism/ˈskeptɪsɪzəm/an attitude of doubting things until you see proof
cynicism/ˈsɪnɪsɪzəm/the belief that people are always selfish or dishonest
off the hook/ˌɒf ðə ˈhʊk/free from blame or responsibility
corrosive/kəˈrəʊsɪv/slowly damaging or destroying something
overpromising/ˌəʊvəˈprɒmɪsɪŋ/promising more than you can really do
sobering/ˈsəʊbərɪŋ/making you feel serious and thoughtful

Trust in Institutions: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.