Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 30 · Essay · 880 words

Is Mathematics Invented or Discovered?

An essay weighing the case for mathematics as a discovery of objective truths against the view that it is a human creation, and exploring a middle position.

Ask a working mathematician whether she invents or discovers, and the honest answer may depend on the day of the week. On a good morning, when a proof falls into place with a click of certainty, it feels like finding something that was there all along, like a fossil waiting in the rock. On a bad afternoon, buried in definitions she chose herself, it feels more like building an elaborate machine and then being surprised by what it does. The philosophical question behind this ordinary experience is one of the oldest there is, and it has never been settled.

The case for discovery is usually called Platonism, after the Greek philosopher who held that the perfect forms of things exist in a realm beyond the senses. The modern Platonist need not believe in a heavenly warehouse of triangles, but she does believe that mathematical truths are objective and independent of us. There are infinitely many prime numbers; this was proved more than two thousand years ago, and it would be true if no human being had ever lived. We did not decide it. We found it out. Mathematicians in different centuries and on different continents, working in complete isolation from one another, have repeatedly arrived at the same results, which is just what you would expect if they were exploring a common landscape.

Then there is the uncanny fit between mathematics and the physical world. In 1960 the physicist Eugene Wigner wrote a celebrated essay on what he called 'the unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in the natural sciences'. His puzzle was this: structures developed for purely internal reasons, out of curiosity or a taste for elegance, keep turning out to describe nature with startling precision. Geometries in which the familiar rules about parallel lines no longer hold were explored in the nineteenth century as abstract possibilities; decades later, Einstein found that geometry of this kind was exactly what he needed to describe gravity. Numbers built on the square root of minus one, once dismissed as 'imaginary', became indispensable to quantum physics. If mathematics were merely a human invention, why should the universe keep obliging it?

The opposing camp is less united, but its members share a suspicion that Platonism mistakes a feeling for a fact. Formalists have compared mathematics to chess: a game played with symbols according to rules we have chosen. Nobody thinks the rules of chess were waiting to be discovered. Others point out that mathematics is shaped by human bodies and human needs. We count in tens because we have ten fingers; the earliest geometry grew out of measuring fields and building walls. The nineteenth-century mathematician Leopold Kronecker is said to have remarked that God made the whole numbers, and all else is the work of man, a quip that concedes something to each side.

As for Wigner's puzzle, sceptics argue that it is less mysterious than it looks. We remember the cases in which abstract mathematics found a use and forget the vast tracts of it that never did. Moreover, mathematics is largely the study of pattern, and a universe that contains any regularities at all (and one that produced us must) is bound to resemble some of the patterns we can imagine. On this view the effectiveness is not unreasonable but inevitable, a little like being amazed that a key cut to fit a lock really does open it.

History supplies a delicious irony here. In 1940 the English mathematician G. H. Hardy published A Mathematician's Apology, a short and moving defence of pure mathematics. He took particular pride in number theory, his own field, on the grounds that it was beautiful and almost entirely useless; it could never, he believed, be put to any warlike purpose. Within a few decades the properties of prime numbers had become the foundation of the encryption that protects online payments and private messages. Hardy's 'useless' mathematics is now at work billions of times a day. Whether this proves that he had discovered something real, or merely that clever people will find a use for anything, is precisely the question.

Many contemporary thinkers have settled on a middle position that is less a compromise than a refinement. We invent the concepts, it suggests, but we discover their consequences. The rules of chess are a human creation; yet once they are fixed, it is simply a fact, which no committee can overturn, that a bishop which starts on a dark square will never reach a light one. In the same way, nobody was obliged to define the prime numbers, but having done so, we have no say whatever in how they are distributed. The freedom lies in the choosing; the constraint lies in everything that follows.

This answer will not satisfy everyone. The Platonist will ask why, out of all the games we might have invented, the ones that matter most keep converging, and the sceptic will ask where exactly the realm of mathematical objects is supposed to be. Yet the question remains worth asking, not because we are close to an answer but because of what it reveals. Mathematics is the one human activity in which certainty seems genuinely attainable, and we still cannot say what it is certain about. There is something both humbling and exhilarating in that.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
elaborate/ɪˈlæbərət/having many carefully planned parts; complicated
Platonism/ˈpleɪtənɪzəm/the belief that ideas like numbers really exist, outside human minds
objective/əbˈdʒektɪv/true in itself, not depending on anyone's opinion
uncanny/ʌnˈkæni/strange and surprising, in a way that is hard to explain
indispensable/ˌɪndɪˈspensəbl/so important that you cannot manage without it
obliging/əˈblaɪdʒɪŋ/doing what someone wants; being helpful
Formalists/ˈfɔːməlɪsts/people who believe that mathematics is only a game of symbols and rules
quip/kwɪp/a short, clever and funny remark
tracts/trækts/large areas
inevitable/ɪˈnevɪtəbl/certain to happen; impossible to avoid
encryption/ɪnˈkrɪpʃən/changing information into a secret code so that others cannot read it
refinement/rɪˈfaɪnmənt/a small change that makes an idea more exact and better
overturn/ˌəʊvəˈtɜːn/change a decision or result completely
constraint/kənˈstreɪnt/something that limits what you can do
converging/kənˈvɜːdʒɪŋ/coming together towards the same point
attainable/əˈteɪnəbəl/possible to reach or achieve
humbling/ˈhʌmblɪŋ/making you feel less important or less clever than you thought
exhilarating/ɪɡˈzɪləreɪtɪŋ/very exciting and full of energy

Is Mathematics Invented or Discovered?: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.