This is an edited transcript of an episode of 'Long View', a podcast about big questions in science. The host, Leo Hartmann, was joined by the astrophysicist Dr Megan Doyle and the philosopher of science Professor Samir Haddad.
Leo: The story goes that in 1950, at lunch with colleagues at Los Alamos, the physicist Enrico Fermi suddenly asked, 'Where is everybody?' Megan, why was that such a good question? Megan: Because the numbers seem to point one way and the silence points the other. Our galaxy contains hundreds of billions of stars, and we now know that planets are the rule rather than the exception. The galaxy is also billions of years old. Even a civilisation that travelled at a small fraction of the speed of light could, in principle, spread across it in some tens of millions of years, which is a blink on cosmic timescales. So if intelligent life were common, you'd expect some sign of it by now. Instead, we see nothing at all.
Leo: And the Drake equation is meant to help here? Megan: It's often misunderstood. Frank Drake wrote it down in 1961 as an agenda for a meeting, not as a formula that produces an answer. It multiplies together the factors that matter: how many stars form, how many have planets, how many of those planets develop life, intelligence and technology, and how long such civilisations last. The trouble is that for most of those terms we have a sample size of exactly one: us. You can make the answer come out as millions or as zero, depending on your mood. Samir: Which is rather the point. The equation is a beautifully disciplined way of displaying our ignorance.
Leo: Samir, you've argued that the paradox is partly a philosophical problem. Samir: Partly, yes. It isn't a paradox in the strict logical sense; nothing actually contradicts anything. It's a tension between an expectation and an observation, and the interesting question is which of our assumptions we're prepared to give up. The candidate explanations fall roughly into three families. Perhaps intelligent life is extraordinarily rare, which is the so-called 'rare Earth' view. Perhaps it's common, but something stops civilisations before they spread: what's been called a Great Filter. Or perhaps they're out there and we simply haven't noticed, or they've chosen not to make themselves known. Leo: The 'zoo hypothesis'. Samir: Yes, the idea that we're being politely left alone, like animals in a nature reserve. I find it charming, but it has a fatal weakness. It requires every civilisation, over millions of years, to obey the same rule without a single defector. That's asking a lot of any society, let alone thousands of them.
Leo: The Great Filter sounds rather ominous. Megan: It is, and that's why it's worth thinking about carefully. If the filter lies behind us, if, say, the leap from simple cells to complex ones is fantastically unlikely, then we're lucky, and perhaps alone. If it lies ahead of us, then the silence is a warning. That's why some researchers say, only half joking, that they hope our searches on Mars and the icy moons of Jupiter and Saturn find nothing. Discovering that simple life had arisen independently twice in one solar system would suggest that life is cheap, and push the filter uncomfortably into our future.
Leo: Is it possible that we're just not looking properly? Megan: Very possible. Our searches for radio signals have covered a tiny proportion of the sky, the frequencies and the time available. One colleague compared it to scooping a single glass of water from the ocean, finding no fish and concluding that the sea is empty. And we're assuming that other civilisations would use technology we'd recognise. We might be like people listening for drums while everyone else communicates by fibre-optic cable. Samir: I'd add a note of humility about the word 'everybody'. Fermi's question assumes that an advanced civilisation would want to expand, to colonise, to be noticed. Those are rather human ambitions, perhaps rather twentieth-century ones. It's possible that the more advanced a society becomes, the less interested it is in conquest.
Leo: So where does that leave us? Samir: With a genuinely open question, which is rarer than people think. Most of the time, when we say we don't know, we at least know what kind of answer we're looking for. Here we don't even agree on that. Megan: And with a strong reason to keep looking. Either answer would be momentous. If we find someone, the universe becomes a crowded and fascinating place. If we go on finding no one, then the stewardship of the only intelligence we know of becomes a rather heavier responsibility. Leo: On that sobering note, thank you both.