At a dinner party in Bristol last winter, I watched a perfectly pleasant evening curdle over the question of the roast. One guest, a vegan of some years' standing, declined it politely; another, who farms sheep on the edge of Exmoor, asked, rather less politely, whether she knew where her almond milk came from. Nobody shouted, but the conversation never quite recovered. I mention it not because it was unusual but because it was so ordinary. Food has become one of the places where we argue about ethics without admitting that we are doing so.
There is a reason for this. Eating is the one moral act that almost all of us perform several times a day, and it implicates us in systems far larger than the plate: in the lives of animals, the work of farmers and fruit pickers, the use of land and water, and the gases that warm the atmosphere. Few other choices are at once so intimate and so far-reaching. It is small wonder that they feel personal.
The case against eating meat, or at least against eating so much of it, usually rests on two foundations. The first concerns animals themselves. If a creature can suffer, and the scientific evidence that mammals and birds feel pain is by now overwhelming, then the conditions in which it is raised and killed are a moral matter, not merely a commercial one. The second concerns the planet. Studies consistently find that, on average, beef and lamb have a far larger environmental footprint per gram of protein than beans, lentils or grains, because animals need land, feed and water, and because cattle and sheep release methane as they digest. One finding that surprises many people is that transport usually accounts for only a small part of a food's footprint: what we eat tends to matter more than how far it has travelled.
Neither argument, however, is quite as tidy as its supporters sometimes suggest. Averages conceal enormous variation. Sheep grazing on hillsides too steep or wet to plough may turn grass that humans cannot eat into food that they can; a field of soya cleared from rainforest may do more harm than a herd raised on long-established pasture. Nor is a plant-based diet automatically virtuous. Avocados need a great deal of water, some crops depend on poorly paid seasonal labour, and a highly processed vegan burger is not obviously kinder to the soil than a carefully reared chicken. The honest verdict of the evidence is less a single commandment than a set of tendencies.
Then there is the matter of who gets to choose. For many families, the question is not which ethical diet to adopt but which one they can afford, or which shops lie within reach of a bus route. Food is also bound up with memory, religion and belonging: a grandmother's recipe, a festival meal, a dish that tells a family where it came from. Telling people that their traditions are simply wrong is rarely persuasive and often patronising. Moral arguments about food that ignore culture and cost risk becoming a hobby for the comfortable.
Yet to conclude that everything is relative would be a cop-out. The difficulty of drawing exact lines does not mean that no lines exist. Most people already agree that cruelty to animals is wrong; most accept that waste is a problem when a large share of the food produced worldwide is never eaten. Between the absolutist who will compromise on nothing and the shrug of the person who thinks that individual choices cannot matter, there lies a broad and habitable middle ground.
What might living there look like? For some it means eating less meat but better meat, from farms whose standards they trust. For others it means planning meals to waste less, choosing seasonal vegetables, or treating meat as an occasional pleasure rather than a daily default. The philosopher's demand for consistency has its place, but so does the gardener's patience: diets, like soils, tend to change slowly and to repay steady attention more than sudden zeal.
As for the dinner party, the vegan and the sheep farmer ended the evening in the kitchen, washing up and comparing notes on hedgerows. They did not agree. But each, I suspect, went home with a slightly more complicated picture of the other, which is, perhaps, where most useful conversations about the ethics of eating begin.