The following is an edited transcript of a symposium held at a university in Leicester, part of a series on the moral questions raised by a warming world. The chair, Priya Nandakumar, invited three speakers: Dr Samuel Okafor, an economist; Professor Ingrid Halvorsen, a moral philosopher; and Rhiannon Price, a sixth-former from Swansea who campaigns on energy poverty.
Priya Nandakumar: Let me begin with the phrase itself. 'Climate justice' is used so widely now that it risks meaning everything and nothing. Ingrid, what is the core idea? Ingrid Halvorsen: At its simplest, it is the observation that the burdens of climate change and the benefits of the activities that cause it are not shared out evenly. Some countries grew rich over two centuries of burning coal, oil and gas. Many of the places most exposed to droughts, floods and rising seas contributed very little to the problem. When harm and responsibility are so badly mismatched, questions of fairness arise whether we like it or not.
Priya Nandakumar: Samuel, economists are sometimes accused of turning all of this into a ledger. Samuel Okafor: Guilty, up to a point. But a ledger can be clarifying. There are, broadly, three ways of deciding who should do most: who caused the problem, who can best afford to fix it, and who benefited. In practice the three often point in the same direction, which is why the international framework, ever since the early 1990s, has spoken of 'common but differentiated responsibilities'. Everyone has a duty to act; not everyone has the same duty.
Priya Nandakumar: Not everyone accepts the first principle, though. Why should a young person in Manchester today pay for what factory owners did in 1850? Ingrid Halvorsen: That is the strongest objection, and I do not think it should be brushed aside. People are not usually blamed for acts committed before they were born, and for most of the industrial era nobody understood the effects of carbon dioxide on the climate. But there is a difference between blame and responsibility. If I inherit a house, I inherit its leaking roof as well as its garden. Wealthy societies today still enjoy the roads, hospitals and universities that cheap fossil energy helped to build. One can accept that legacy without feeling personally guilty for it.
Rhiannon Price: Can I add something? Justice isn't only a question between countries. In my street, the people who struggle most with heating bills are often the ones living in the draughtiest homes, and they're the least able to afford insulation or a heat pump. If climate policy makes energy dearer without helping them, it'll feel like a punishment, and people will turn against it. Fairness at home isn't a distraction from climate action; it's what makes climate action last. Samuel Okafor: I agree, and the evidence supports you. Policies that are seen as unfair tend to provoke a backlash, however sensible they look on paper.
Priya Nandakumar: Let's turn to the present. Some of the largest emitters today are not the old industrial powers. Does the historical argument still hold? Samuel Okafor: It still holds, but it is complicated. Emissions in several fast-growing economies have risen sharply, and on any reasonable view they must now peak and fall too. Per person, however, emissions in many poorer countries remain far lower than in rich ones, and those countries also have hundreds of millions of people who still need reliable electricity. Asking them to stay poor so that others can stay comfortable would hardly be just. Ingrid Halvorsen: Which is why I prefer to speak of trajectories rather than snapshots. The question is not only who emitted what, but how every country can move towards clean energy at a pace that is fair to its people.
Priya Nandakumar: Rhiannon, you're the youngest person here. Is there a justice question between generations? Rhiannon Price: Obviously, I'd say yes. But I'm wary of turning it into old versus young. My grandad votes, recycles and grows his own vegetables; some of my friends fly abroad three times a year. Generations aren't teams. What I'd ask of older people isn't contrition. It's that they use the power they've got, as voters, investors and constituents, while there's still time for it to make a difference.
Priya Nandakumar: A last question to each of you, briefly. What gives you grounds for cautious optimism? Samuel Okafor: The cost of solar and wind power has fallen far faster than almost anyone predicted. That changes the politics: clean energy is increasingly the cheap option, not the sacrifice. Ingrid Halvorsen: The fact that international talks have at least acknowledged, in principle, that vulnerable countries need help with loss and damage they cannot adapt to. Principles are not cash, but they are a start. Rhiannon Price: That people in my street, who'd never call themselves activists, came out to help insulate the community hall. Justice sounds abstract until it's someone's cold kitchen. Then it's just neighbours.