Stand on the summit of a hill in the Cairngorms on a clear morning and the word arrives almost unbidden: wilderness. Heather and rock stretch to the horizon; there is no road, no house, no sound but the wind. It seems the very opposite of anything human beings have made. And yet the more closely one looks at such places, the more the word begins to wobble.
The English word is old, and for most of its history it was not a compliment. In older English writing, including translations of the Bible, the wilderness was a place of trial and danger, a desert where people were tested, lost or sent into exile. Many travellers in the seventeenth century regarded mountains as ugly, even frightening. It took a profound shift in taste, the Romantic movement of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, with its poets walking the fells of the Lake District, for wild landscapes to become sublime: places of awe rather than mere dread.
In the United States, the idea took official form. Writers such as Henry David Thoreau and John Muir celebrated wild nature as a source of spiritual renewal, and in 1872 Yellowstone became the world's first national park. These were remarkable achievements, and much that is beautiful survives because of them. But the story had a shadow. The lands described as untouched were, in many cases, the homes of Indigenous peoples, who had hunted, burned, planted and managed them for thousands of years. Declaring a landscape 'pristine' often meant overlooking, or removing, the people who had shaped it.
In 1995 the American historian William Cronon published an essay with the deliberately provocative title 'The Trouble with Wilderness'. His argument was not that wild places are worthless; he wrote about them with obvious affection. It was that the idea of wilderness as nature untouched by humans is itself a human creation, and a misleading one. If we locate true nature only in remote mountains, he suggested, we may come to think of the places where we actually live, such as farms, towns and city parks, as spoilt and unworthy of care. The essay provoked fierce replies, and it still does.
Britain offers its own version of the puzzle. The open, treeless moorland that visitors to the Highlands often admire as wild is, to a considerable extent, a product of human history: centuries of tree felling, grazing by sheep and deer, and the burning of heather. In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, many Highland communities were forced from their homes during the Clearances, so that some apparently empty glens are empty because people were made to leave. To call such a landscape untouched is not exactly false, since few people live there now, but it is a half-truth.
Critics of Cronon's position worry that such arguments can be pressed into service by those who would like to build on or exploit wild land. If wilderness is merely an idea, why protect it? Ecologists also point out that the difference between more and less altered places is real, even if it is a matter of degree. An ancient forest that has never been cleared differs in measurable ways, in the age of its trees, the richness of its fungi and the creatures it shelters, from a plantation of identical conifers. To admit that our ideas are shaped by culture is not to say that nothing lies beneath them.
Perhaps the most useful answer is that wilderness is both a human idea and something more than one. The word is ours, with all its history of fear, longing and politics; the mountains, rivers and lichens are not. What the idea can do, when it is held with humility, is remind us that there are processes far older and larger than our purposes. What it should not do is persuade us that care for nature belongs only in faraway places, or that the people who have lived among such landscapes are intruders in them.
Recent conservation thinking reflects this reconciliation. Many projects now speak less of keeping people out and more of working with local and Indigenous communities, whose knowledge of the land is often unrivalled. Others try to bring wildness back into ordinary places: a city river freed from its concrete channel, a churchyard left unmown in May. The hill in the Cairngorms is no less magnificent for having a history. If anything, knowing that history allows us to see it more clearly: not as a picture of a world without us, but as one chapter in a long, shared and unfinished story.