On a damp October morning in a pine wood near Inverness, Dr Morag Lindsay crouches beside a feeder and points out the small, tufted ears of a red squirrel. 'Twenty years ago you'd hardly have seen one here,' she says. The reason for their return is not, she admits, entirely comfortable to explain. Part of it involves pine martens, a native predator that has recovered in many areas; part of it involves the culling of grey squirrels, a species introduced from North America that outcompetes the reds and carries a virus that is deadly to them.
Conservation is often imagined as a simply kind activity: planting trees, rescuing hedgehogs, protecting what is beautiful. In practice it is shot through with dilemmas, choices between good things that cannot all be had at once. Should we kill some animals to save others? Should scarce funds go to the rarest species or to the most useful habitats? Whose interests count when a returning species is welcome to some people and costly to others?
I put the first question to Dr Lindsay directly. Journalist: Does it trouble you that saving one squirrel involves killing another? Morag Lindsay: Of course it does. Nobody goes into ecology because they like killing things. But the greys didn't arrive by accident. People released them, in the nineteenth century, as an ornamental novelty. Doing nothing isn't neutral. It's a decision to let the reds disappear from most of Britain. Journalist: Some animal welfare groups would say that individual animals matter, whatever their species. Morag Lindsay: And they have a point. That's why the methods matter so much, and why I'm genuinely excited about alternatives: encouraging pine martens, for instance, or research into fertility control. If we can reach the same goal with less killing, we should.
Further south, the dilemma takes a different shape. Beavers, hunted to extinction in Britain several centuries ago, have returned to a number of rivers, some through official schemes and some through unofficial releases. Their dams slow floodwater, create wetlands and provide homes for insects, fish and birds. They can also flood fields and fell trees that farmers would rather keep.
Tom Hesketh, whose family has farmed beside a river in Cumbria for four generations, is ambivalent. 'I like seeing them, honestly. The kids love it. But when a field I've drained for forty years turns into a pond, it's not the person who wrote the policy who pays for it.' His grievance is one that conservationists increasingly take seriously. Schemes that compensate farmers, or pay them for the wetland they host, are one response; another is simply to involve local people early, before decisions are announced rather than after.
A third dilemma is less visible but perhaps more fundamental. Money for conservation is limited, and some scientists argue openly for triage: concentrating resources where they are most likely to succeed, even if that means accepting the loss of some species that are very expensive to save. The word comes from emergency medicine, and it is meant to sound unsentimental. Opponents find it chilling. Once we start ranking species by value for money, they ask, where does it end? And who decides that a plain-looking beetle is worth less than a photogenic bird?
Between these positions, a pragmatic consensus of sorts has emerged. Many ecologists now favour protecting and connecting whole habitats rather than rescuing species one by one, on the grounds that healthy ecosystems shelter countless creatures, celebrated and obscure alike. Others stress that some species are 'keystones', whose presence holds a whole system together, and deserve special attention. None of this removes the need for hard choices, but it can make them less arbitrary.
Back in the pine wood, Dr Lindsay watches the squirrel vanish up a trunk. 'People want conservation to be a story with heroes and villains,' she says. 'Usually it's a story of trade-offs, made by people doing their best with incomplete information. The trick is to be honest about that, and to keep checking whether we got it right.' It is, perhaps, the most reassuring thing a conservationist could say: not that the choices are easy, but that they are being made with open eyes.