Anyone who reads widely about the climate soon learns to recognise two registers. The first is the register of alarm: melting ice, burning forests, graphs that climb like cliffs. The second is the register of reassurance: clever technologies, falling prices, cities that are greening themselves. Each has its devoted readers, and each has its critics, who accuse the first of paralysing people and the second of lulling them to sleep. The argument between them has become one of the defining literary quarrels of our time.
It is not a new quarrel. When Rachel Carson published Silent Spring in 1962, she opened with a short fable about a town in which the birds had fallen silent. The book was frightening by design, and it helped to change laws on the use of pesticides. Yet Carson was no prophet of doom. Her prose is full of wonder at the living world, and her purpose was not to make readers despair but to make them pay attention. Fear, in her hands, was a means rather than an end.
The modern literature of catastrophe has its defenders. They argue that the scale of the danger is genuinely enormous, and that softening it amounts to a kind of dishonesty. A writer, on this view, owes readers the truth, not comfort. There is also a long literary tradition, from ancient tragedy onwards, in which facing the worst is itself a form of dignity. To look unflinchingly at loss, these writers say, is not the same as giving up.
Critics reply that endless doom can defeat its own purpose. Psychologists who study the subject have found that messages of pure threat, without any sense of what might be done, can lead people to switch off, or to conclude that nothing they do will matter. Some readers, especially young ones, describe a kind of climate anxiety that leaves them exhausted rather than galvanised. A literature that only mourns risks becoming, in the words of the critic Helena Marsh, 'an elegy written before the funeral'.
But the literature of hope has its own pitfalls. At its weakest, it slides into complacency: a sunny insistence that markets or inventions will sort everything out, which can make action seem unnecessary. It can also feel glib to people already living with floods or failed harvests. Hope that refuses to look at the evidence is not hope at all, Marsh argues, but 'optimism with its fingers in its ears'.
What, then, does the best climate writing do? Reading across the past few decades, one notices that the books which last tend to refuse the choice altogether. They hold grief and resolve together. They describe what has been lost with precision and tenderness, and then turn, without forcing it, to what can still be protected or rebuilt. They are specific: a particular marsh, a particular town's flood defences, a particular group of volunteers counting moths. Specificity matters because despair grows strongest in the abstract. 'The planet' is too vast to love or save; a river can be both.
Several writers have drawn a useful distinction between optimism and hope. Optimism, in this account, is a forecast: the belief that things will turn out well. Hope is closer to a stance: the decision to act as though one's actions might matter, without any guarantee that they will. Optimism can be refuted by bad news; hope, understood in this way, is more resilient, because it was never a prediction in the first place.
None of this means that writers should ration their honesty. Readers can tell when they are being managed, and they rarely forgive it. The task is harder and more interesting than choosing between alarm and comfort. It is to tell the truth about the scale of the problem while keeping open the possibility of response: to write, as it were, with one eye on the flood and one on the people filling sandbags. That double vision may be the most valuable thing literature can offer a frightened age: not a promise that all will be well, but a reason to keep going.