Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 81 · Essay · 746 words

How History Is Written

An essay on how historians from Herodotus to E. H. Carr and E. P. Thompson have selected, questioned and argued about the past, and why that makes history a discipline rather than mere opinion.

Every history book begins with a quiet act of selection. Before a single sentence is written, the historian has already decided which period matters, which people deserve attention and which of the countless surviving traces will be allowed to speak. Readers rarely notice this, because a well-made narrative conceals its own scaffolding. Yet to ask how history is written is to ask, in effect, whose past we are being invited to remember, and on what terms.

The question is as old as the discipline itself. Herodotus, writing in the fifth century BC and often called the 'father of history', opened his inquiries by declaring that he wished to preserve the great deeds of Greeks and others from being forgotten. He collected stories from travellers and priests, reported versions he plainly doubted and occasionally left his readers to choose between them. His successor Thucydides was rather less indulgent: he promised accuracy rather than entertainment and dismissed tales that merely pleased the ear. From the very beginning, then, history has been pulled between two impulses: the wish to tell a compelling story and the duty to establish what can actually be known.

In the nineteenth century the second impulse seemed to triumph. The German historian Leopold von Ranke urged his students to show the past 'as it actually was', and the modern seminar, with its rigorous scrutiny of documents, was largely his legacy. Ranke's ideal was admirable, but it carried a hidden assumption: that the documents in state archives were neutral windows onto events, rather than records produced by particular officials for particular purposes. The diplomat's despatch survived; the grumbling of the dockside rarely did.

A century later, the Cambridge historian E. H. Carr punctured that confidence in a famous series of lectures, published in 1961 as What Is History? Facts, he suggested, are not like fish lying on a fishmonger's slab, waiting to be collected. They are more like fish swimming in a vast ocean: what the historian catches depends partly on chance, but mainly on where he chooses to fish and what tackle he uses. Carr was not claiming that facts are invented; he was insisting that they become historical only when someone selects them and asks a question of them.

Others went further in widening the net. In France, the historians associated with the journal Annales, founded in 1929, turned away from kings and battles towards climate, trade, diet and the slow rhythms of everyday life. In Britain, E. P. Thompson set out in 1963 to rescue ordinary working people from what he memorably called 'the enormous condescension of posterity'. Social historians, women's historians and historians of empire have since recovered voices that earlier scholars had not so much suppressed as simply failed to hear.

None of this means that history is merely opinion dressed up in footnotes. The popular saying that 'history is written by the victors' contains a grain of truth, but it flatters the cynic. Victors have often written the first draft; they have seldom written the last. Defeated peoples keep their own memories, rival scholars check one another's sources, and new evidence, such as a cache of letters, a set of tax returns or a skeleton under a car park, can overturn a reputation that seemed secure for centuries. Historical knowledge advances not because historians are free of bias but because their biases are exposed to argument, in public, by people who have every incentive to find fault.

Perhaps the most honest way to describe the craft is as a conversation that never quite ends. Each generation returns to the past with its own anxieties, and finds in it answers to questions its predecessors did not think to ask. Interest in the history of public health, for instance, tends to rise sharply after an epidemic. This is not a defect of the discipline but a condition of it. The danger lies not in asking new questions but in forgetting that the answers we prefer are not necessarily the ones the evidence supports. A good historian, like a good witness, must be willing to be cross-examined.

So when we open a history book, it is worth reading it twice: once for the story it tells, and once for the choices it has made. Who is quoted, and who is merely counted? Which sources are trusted, and which are passed over in silence? Such questions do not undermine history. They are, in the end, what makes it a discipline rather than a creed.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
scaffolding/ˈskæfəldɪŋ/here: the hidden structure and decisions that hold a piece of writing together
indulgent/ɪnˈdʌldʒənt/willing to accept or allow things that a stricter person would reject
impulses/ˈɪmpʌlsɪz/strong natural wishes or urges to do something
seminar/ˈsemɪnɑː/a university class where a small group studies and discusses a subject in depth
scrutiny/ˈskruːtɪni/very careful and critical examination
punctured/ˈpʌŋktʃəd/suddenly weakened or destroyed (a feeling or belief), like letting the air out of a balloon
tackle/ˈtækəl/the equipment used for fishing, such as rods, lines and hooks
condescension/ˌkɒndɪˈsenʃən/the attitude of looking down on people as if they were less important
posterity/pɒˈsterəti/all the people who will live in the future; later generations
suppressed/səˈprest/deliberately kept hidden or prevented from being heard
cynic/ˈsɪnɪk/a person who believes that people act only for selfish reasons and expects the worst
overturn/ˌəʊvəˈtɜːn/to reverse or completely change a decision or belief
bias/ˈbaɪəs/a tendency to favour one side or view unfairly
defect/ˈdiːfekt/a fault or weakness
cross-examined/ˌkrɒs ɪɡˈzæmɪnd/questioned closely, as a witness is questioned in court, to test whether they are telling the truth
undermine/ˌʌndəˈmaɪn/to weaken something gradually
creed/kriːd/a set of beliefs that people accept without questioning

How History Is Written: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.