In the late 1960s the French critic Roland Barthes published a short essay with a deliberately provocative title: 'The Death of the Author'. Few pieces of literary theory have travelled so far beyond the university. The phrase is now quoted by fans arguing over the meaning of a television series, by students resisting a teacher's interpretation, and by novelists who are tired of being asked what they 'really meant'. Like many famous slogans, it is more often repeated than read.
Barthes's target was a habit of criticism that he thought had become tyrannical: the assumption that a work's meaning is to be found by consulting the life and intentions of the person who wrote it. To explain a novel by the novelist's childhood, or a poem by the poet's unhappy love affair, was in his view to impose a limit on the text – to give it a single, final meaning, and so to close it. Against this he proposed a different picture. A text, he argued, is not a line of words releasing one message from an 'author-god', but a multi-dimensional space in which many writings, none of them original, blend and clash. It is a tissue of quotations drawn from countless centres of culture.
If meaning does not come from the author, where does it come from? Barthes's answer was the reader. The unity of a text, he wrote, lies not in its origin but in its destination. His essay ends with a celebrated reversal: the birth of the reader must be paid for by the death of the Author. It is worth noticing what this does and does not claim. Barthes was not saying that writers do not exist, or that their biographies are uninteresting. He was making a claim about authority – about who has the right to settle what a text means.
The essay did not appear from nowhere. Two decades earlier, the American critics W. K. Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley had described what they called the 'intentional fallacy': the mistake of judging a poem by what its author intended rather than by what it actually achieves. And shortly after Barthes, the philosopher Michel Foucault asked, in a lecture entitled 'What is an Author?', how the very idea of an author functions – how a name on a cover helps us to classify, value and control a body of writing. What distinguished Barthes was his tone. Where Wimsatt and Beardsley were cautious, he was exuberant; where Foucault was historical, he was almost polemical.
Half a century on, how well has the idea aged? Its liberating effect is easy to see. It gave readers permission to find meanings an author never planned, and to take seriously the responses of people the author never imagined: readers of different centuries, countries and backgrounds. It also discouraged a lazy kind of criticism that treated literature as a puzzle with a solution locked in the writer's diary.
Yet the slogan has its costs, and they are worth stating plainly. Taken literally, it can license carelessness: if the reader alone decides, why should any interpretation be better than another? In practice, almost no one reads like this. When we learn that a novel was written in exile, or under censorship, or as a reply to another book, our reading usually becomes richer rather than poorer. Context is not a prison; it is often a key. There is also an awkward irony in the history of the phrase itself. Barthes's essay is constantly cited as Barthes's – its authority depends on the name of its author.
A more modest version of the argument survives this objection. One may grant that authors' intentions are relevant without granting that they are final. A writer's account of her own book is one reading among others – usually an informed one, sometimes a revealing one, but not one that trumps everything the text itself makes possible. Novelists, in fact, are frequently surprised by what readers find in their work, and many say that the book they wrote is not quite the book that was read.
Perhaps the most useful way to understand 'the death of the author', then, is as a metaphor rather than a verdict. Barthes was not burying writers; he was moving the furniture, shifting attention from the study where a book is written to the countless rooms where it is read. Whether that move is a revolution or simply a change of emphasis depends, appropriately enough, on the reader.