Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 53 · Symposium · 697 words

The Avant-Garde

An edited transcript of a festival panel in which an art historian, a composer and a critic debate where the avant-garde came from, what it achieved and whether it still exists.

The following is an edited transcript of a panel discussion held at a festival of ideas in Bath. The chair, Miriam Holt, was joined by the art historian Dr Tomasz Wierzbicki, the composer Sasha Greene and the critic Professor Alan Prentice.

Holt: Let's begin with the word itself. Tomasz, where does it come from? Wierzbicki: From the military. The avant-garde was the advance guard – the troops who went ahead of the main army, into unknown territory, and took the first fire. In the nineteenth century the term was borrowed, first for political radicals and then for artists, and it has never quite lost its martial swagger. The image is of a small band of pioneers, with everyone else following at a safe distance. Holt: And the moments people usually point to? Wierzbicki: Paris supplies many of them, though not all. In 1863 the paintings rejected by the official Salon were shown in a separate exhibition, the Salon des Refusés, and a great many visitors came largely to laugh. Fifty years later, the first performance of Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring very nearly turned into a riot. And in 1917 Marcel Duchamp submitted a shop-bought urinal, signed 'R. Mutt', to an exhibition in New York.

Greene: I'd like to puncture the heroic story a little. The myth is that the avant-garde is always shocking and always right, and the public is always slow and always wrong. But plenty of experiments were simply bad, and we've forgotten them. We remember the Rite because it turned out to be a masterpiece, not because it caused a scandal. Scandal is cheap. Prentice: Cheaper now than ever. That's my worry. The avant-garde needed something to push against – an academy, a set of rules, a public with firm expectations. Today the market has learnt to absorb shock almost instantly. A gesture that would once have closed a gallery now gets a sponsor and a gift shop. When everything is permitted, transgression becomes a style, and a rather tired one.

Holt: So is the avant-garde dead? Prentice: Its obituary has been written many times. Let's say it has retired to the provinces and is living comfortably on its royalties. Wierzbicki: I'd dispute that. The original avant-gardes weren't only about shock. They asked what art was for and who it was for. Duchamp's question – can a choice, an idea, turn an ordinary object into art? – is still very much alive. Students argue about it every year, and they should. Greene: And in music the frontier simply moved. When John Cage's 4'33" was first performed in 1952, a pianist sat at the instrument for four minutes and thirty-three seconds without deliberately playing a note. People thought it was a joke. Cage's point was that there's no such thing as true silence: you hear the rain, the coughing, your own heartbeat. Some of the most radical work today happens in sound installations, in galleries and empty buildings, and it's still asking Cage's question about what counts as music.

Holt: We have a question from the audience. A student asks whether the avant-garde was always a rather elitist affair – art made by a few for a few. Greene: Sometimes, yes. There's a strain of contempt for the audience in some of it that I find unattractive. But the best of it was generous. It assumed the public could cope with more than it was being offered. Prentice: I'd add that 'difficult' and 'elitist' aren't the same thing. A difficult work asks for effort; an elitist one asks for credentials. The first is a compliment to the audience. The second is an insult. Wierzbicki: And yesterday's difficulty becomes today's furniture. The Impressionists were mocked when they first exhibited; now they sell calendars and biscuit tins. That isn't a defeat, by the way. It's what success looks like for a revolution in taste.

Holt: We're almost out of time. A final word from each of you. Prentice: Distrust anything that announces itself as the future. Greene: Distrust anything that announces itself as the past, too. Wierzbicki: Look before you laugh. The visitors who laughed in 1863 are forgotten; the paintings they laughed at are not.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
took the first fire/ˌtʊk ðə ˈfɜːst ˈfaɪə/were the first to be shot at by the enemy
martial/ˈmɑːʃəl/connected with soldiers and war
pioneers/ˌpaɪəˈnɪəz/the first people to go somewhere new or do something new
puncture/ˈpʌŋktʃə/(here) to make an idea seem less grand by showing its weak points
absorb/əbˈzɔːb/to take something in so that it becomes part of you and no longer stands out
transgression/trænzˈɡreʃən/the act of breaking rules or going beyond accepted limits
obituary/əˈbɪtʃuəri/an article about a person's life, published soon after they die
royalties/ˈrɔɪəltiz/money paid to an artist or writer each time their work is sold or used
frontier/ˈfrʌntɪə/the furthest limit of what is known or has been done
installations/ˌɪnstəˈleɪʃnz/works of art made for a particular space, which people can walk into or around
elitist/ɪˈliːtɪst/made for or controlled by a small group of people who think they are better than others
contempt/kənˈtempt/a feeling that someone is worthless and deserves no respect
credentials/krəˈdenʃəlz/qualifications or signs that show you belong to a special group

The Avant-Garde: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.