There is a moment, about ten minutes into Steve Reich's Music for 18 Musicians, when you stop listening for what will happen next and start listening to what is happening now. It arrived on Saturday night at the Wharf Rooms, a converted warehouse by the canal in Leeds, during a luminous performance by the Calder Ensemble – and it is the whole point.
Written between 1974 and 1976, the piece lasts about an hour and has no interval, no soloist and no conventional melody to speak of. It opens with a cycle of eleven chords, played as a steady pulse by pianos, marimbas and xylophones and sustained by voices and clarinets for as long as a breath allows. Each of those chords then becomes the basis of a section of its own, so that the opening works rather like the table of contents of a book you then read slowly, chapter by chapter. Changes are cued not by a conductor but by a vibraphone, whose short melodic patterns signal to the players that it is time to move on.
It is worth remembering how strange all this sounded half a century ago. In the 1950s and 1960s, much 'serious' new music, in Europe especially, prized complexity: dense, dissonant structures in which no note was allowed to dominate and repetition was almost a sin. The composers who came to be called minimalists – Reich, Philip Glass, Terry Riley, La Monte Young – took the opposite path. Riley's In C, from 1964, consists of fifty-three short phrases that each performer repeats as many times as they wish before moving on. Reich discovered his technique of 'phasing' almost by accident, when two tape loops of the same recording, played on machines running at slightly different speeds, drifted gradually out of step and produced patterns that neither contained on its own.
The label itself, borrowed from the visual arts, was never much loved by the composers it described, and it is in some ways misleading. There is nothing minimal about eighteen or more players locked in concentration for an hour. What is reduced is not the amount of music but the number of things competing for your attention. Harmony changes slowly; rhythm is constant; the surface shimmers while the foundations barely move. The effect is less like following an argument than like watching light shift across a field.
Not everyone is persuaded. Early critics dismissed minimalism as wallpaper, music that asked nothing of the listener and so gave nothing back. More recently, it has been accused of a kind of complicity in its own success: its pulsing textures have been so widely imitated in film scores and advertisements that the originals can sound, to younger ears, like the soundtrack to a documentary about cloud formations. These objections deserve better than a shrug. Repetition can be hypnotic, but it can also be merely monotonous, and much music written in this idiom since the 1970s has been content with the hypnosis without earning it.
Saturday's performance was a reminder of what the best of it achieves. Led from the first piano by Leah Okonkwo, the Calder players brought a rare precision to the pulse, but never a mechanical one. The four singers, placed slightly behind the instruments, were especially fine: their long, swelling notes rose and faded like waves breaking on a shore, giving the music a breath that no machine could imitate. In one of the later sections, where the harmony seems to hover between two keys without settling on either, there was a stillness in the room I have rarely heard at a concert of any kind. Not a programme rustled.
If there was a weakness, it lay in the acoustics. The warehouse's brick walls gave the marimbas a slight haze, and in the busier passages some detail was lost. A few listeners left at the halfway mark, which is their right; an hour of gradual change is not for every evening. But the standing ovation that greeted the final, fading pulse suggested that most had found what Reich, in an essay of 1968, called the pleasure of music as a gradual process – and had discovered, perhaps to their surprise, that patience can be its own reward.