The cloud came down while we were still an hour from the summit. One minute the Cairngorm plateau stretched away under a pale October sky; the next, the world had shrunk to a circle of grey granite a few metres wide, and the wind had begun to make a sound I can only describe as industrial. My companion, a retired geography teacher named Morag, checked the compass, said 'Right, then,' and we turned for home. I have rarely been so frightened, and I have rarely felt so alive. Philosophers have a word for that combination, and the word is 'sublime'.
The term is ancient – a Greek treatise on elevated style, attributed to an author known as Longinus, first gave it currency – but the modern idea was largely shaped in the eighteenth century. In 1757 the Irish-born statesman and writer Edmund Burke published A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful, in which he drew a sharp distinction between the two. Beauty, for Burke, was small, smooth, gentle and pleasing; it inspired love. The sublime was vast, dark, rugged and powerful; it inspired something closer to terror. Crucially, though, this terror had to be felt at a safe distance. A storm watched from a sheltered cliff top could be sublime; the same storm experienced from a sinking ship would simply be terrifying.
It is worth pausing on how new this attitude was. Many seventeenth-century travellers crossing the Alps described the mountains as ugly, forbidding obstacles, to be endured rather than admired. Within a few generations, the same peaks had become destinations. The Romantic poets sought them out; Wordsworth, recalling a boyhood night on Ullswater, described a huge black peak that seemed to rise up and stride after him, leaving him troubled for days. The German painter Caspar David Friedrich, in Wanderer above the Sea of Fog, painted around 1818, placed a solitary figure on a rocky summit, his back to us, gazing out over a landscape dissolving into mist. We do not see his face; we are invited to stand where he stands.
Immanuel Kant offered the most ingenious account of why such experiences please us. Faced with something so vast or so powerful that our senses cannot take it in, we feel at first small and overwhelmed. But then something reverses. We realise that we can still think the idea of infinity, even if we cannot picture it; that we can still judge the storm, even if we cannot resist it. The sublime, on this view, is not finally in the mountain at all. It is in the mind's discovery that it is larger, in one sense, than anything nature can throw at it.
There is something faintly self-congratulatory in this, and modern readers have not been slow to point it out. The sublime, as the eighteenth century imagined it, was largely the experience of well-off men with the leisure to seek out danger and the means to retreat from it. The shepherd on the fell and the fisherman on a storm-tossed loch could hardly afford to find their surroundings thrilling. Meanwhile, the mountains themselves were being reshaped by the very attention that celebrated them: roads, hotels and, eventually, the queue for the summit photograph.
Something stranger has happened in our own time. Burke's sublime depended on nature being more powerful than we are. In an age of shrinking glaciers and changing coastlines, that assumption looks less secure. A glacier that once inspired pure awe now inspires a more complicated emotion, mixed with grief and a sense of responsibility – the uneasy feeling that we are no longer only the spectators of nature's power but participants in its transformation. Some writers have begun to speak of a 'toxic sublime' or a 'human sublime', in which the overwhelming spectacle is of our own making.
And yet the older experience has not vanished. On the way down from the plateau that afternoon, the cloud tore open for a few seconds, and we saw, far below, the dark water of a loch and a single shaft of sunlight moving across it like a searchlight. Morag stopped. Neither of us said anything. I do not think either of us was congratulating our faculty of reason. What I felt was simpler and harder to name: a sense of being briefly let in on the scale of things, and of being, for once, entirely content to be small.