Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 45 · Essay · 806 words

The Art of Silence

A reflective essay on silence in music, conversation, theatre and daily life, arguing that silence is full of meaning and must be interpreted like speech.

In 1952, an audience in Woodstock, New York, watched a pianist walk on stage, sit down at the instrument, close its lid and, for four minutes and thirty-three seconds, play nothing at all. The piece was John Cage's 4′33″, and it is still sometimes described as a joke or a provocation. It was neither, or not only. What the audience heard – wind in the trees, rain on the roof, the murmurs and then the protests of their neighbours – was precisely the point. Not long before, Cage had visited a specially built room at Harvard University designed to absorb every echo, and had been surprised to hear two sounds, one high and one low. His own nervous system and his blood in circulation, he was told. Total silence, he concluded, does not exist; what we call silence is simply the sound we have not been paying attention to.

If silence is less empty than it seems, it is also less simple. Consider conversation. Researchers who have recorded and timed ordinary exchanges in languages across the world have found that the gap between one speaker finishing and the next beginning is typically tiny – around a fifth of a second – and that the variation between cultures, though real, is smaller than stereotypes suggest. Within that narrow margin, however, a slightly longer pause can carry enormous weight. Ask a friend whether they enjoyed the meal you cooked and wait an extra second for the answer: you will have learnt most of what you need to know before they say a word. Silence, in other words, is not the opposite of communication. It is one of its most eloquent instruments.

Different communities nonetheless value silence in different ways. In some, a comfortable silence between people who have just met is a sign of respect or thoughtfulness; in others, it is felt as an awkwardness to be filled as quickly as possible. Travellers often report that a pause they intended as polite was taken as coldness, or that a stream of friendly chatter was received as a failure to listen. Such generalisations must be handled with care – individuals vary at least as much as nations do – but the misunderstandings they describe are real, and they remind us that silence, like speech, has to be interpreted.

Writers have long understood this. The playwright Harold Pinter became so famous for his pauses that 'Pinteresque' entered the language to describe dialogue in which what is left unsaid matters more than what is said. In his plays, characters talk about the weather, or the price of a sandwich, while something far more troubling moves beneath the surface; the silences are where the real drama takes place. Pinter's scripts distinguish between a 'pause' and the longer 'silence', and actors learn to give each its own charged quality. Poets, too, know that the white space around a short poem is part of the poem, and that a line break is a small breath of silence that shapes how the words land.

Silence also has a long history as a shared practice. In a traditional Quaker meeting for worship, people sit together in stillness, sometimes for an hour, speaking only if they feel moved to do so. Monastic communities in several religious traditions have kept periods of silence for centuries, and the modern fashion for meditation retreats suggests that many people now seek out what earlier generations could take for granted. There is something paradoxical in this: we pay, sometimes handsomely, to be given nothing to listen to.

That we have to seek it out says a good deal about how we live. Silence has become a scarce resource, crowded out by traffic, notifications and the background music of shops and restaurants. Some cities now map their 'quiet areas' as carefully as their parks, and acoustic ecologists – people who study the sounds of places – warn that undisturbed natural soundscapes are becoming hard to find. Yet the deepest threat may be less to silence in the air than to silence in the mind. The habit of filling every idle moment with a screen or a podcast leaves little room for the kind of unstructured reflection from which ideas so often arise.

None of this means that silence is always good. There is the silence of a person too frightened to speak, the silence of a group that looks away from an injustice, the silence that is really a refusal. To praise silence indiscriminately would be as foolish as to praise speech indiscriminately. The art lies in knowing which is which – in learning, as Cage's audience was invited to learn, to listen to what silence contains. A well-placed pause can say 'I am thinking about what you said', or 'I don't know', or simply 'I am here'. Few words manage as much.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
provocation/ˌprɒvəˈkeɪʃən/something done on purpose to shock people or make them react
murmurs/ˈmɜːməz/quiet, low sounds of people speaking
margin/ˈmɑːdʒɪn/a small amount of space or time
eloquent/ˈeləkwənt/expressing meaning clearly and powerfully
unsaid/ʌnˈsed/not spoken, although it is thought or felt
charged/tʃɑːdʒd/full of strong feeling or tension
stillness/ˈstɪlnəs/a state of being quiet and not moving
monastic/məˈnæstɪk/connected with monks or nuns and the places where they live
paradoxical/ˌpærəˈdɒksɪkəl/seeming to contradict itself, but possibly true
handsomely/ˈhænsəmli/(of paying) a lot of money
scarce/skeəs/hard to find because there is not much of it
crowded out/ˌkraʊdɪd ˈaʊt/pushed out because other things take up all the space
soundscapes/ˈsaʊndskeɪps/all the sounds that you can hear in a particular place
unstructured/ʌnˈstrʌktʃəd/without a fixed plan or organisation
looks away/ˌlʊks əˈweɪ/chooses not to notice or deal with something
indiscriminately/ˌɪndɪˈskrɪmɪnətli/without thinking carefully about which things deserve it

The Art of Silence: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.