Few literary forms are as easy to parody as nature writing. The solitary walker, the dawn chorus, the sudden epiphany beside a heron: the clichés practically write themselves, and a weary reader may suspect that the genre exists chiefly to reassure city-dwellers that the countryside is still there. Yet the best nature writing has always been something stranger and more demanding than a pleasant stroll in prose. It is, at its heart, a discipline of attention, and attention, as any birdwatcher knows, is harder than it looks.
The English tradition is usually traced back to Gilbert White, the eighteenth-century clergyman whose Natural History of Selborne, published in 1789, recorded the comings and goings of swifts, tortoises and earthworms in a single Hampshire parish with a patience that still astonishes. White was not trying to be lyrical; he was trying to be accurate. That, paradoxically, is why he remains so readable. His sentences have the unhurried confidence of a man who has looked at the same hedge for decades and found it inexhaustible.
Across the Atlantic, Henry David Thoreau's Walden (1854) added a philosophical and political edge, turning two years in a cabin beside a pond into an argument about how to live. A century later, Rachel Carson's Silent Spring (1962) showed that a book about birds and insects could alter public policy, helping to bring about restrictions on the pesticides it described. These writers are often bracketed together as 'nature writers', but the label conceals real differences of temperament: White the meticulous observer, Thoreau the provocateur, Carson the scientist who wrote with the urgency of an advocate.
It is into this crowded field that Miriam Holloway steps with Small Weathers, a collection of essays written over a single year on the edge of the Somerset Levels. Holloway is a former meteorologist, and it shows. Where many of her contemporaries reach for the sublime, she is drawn to the minor and the overlooked: frost patterns on a gatepost, the smell of rain on dry earth, the way a flock of starlings thickens and thins above the reed beds like smoke that has changed its mind. Her eye for detail is matched by an ear for rhythm; several passages are best read aloud.
The book's great strength is its refusal to moralise. Holloway knows perfectly well that the landscape she describes is under pressure, drained, farmed, flooded and warmed, yet she rarely tells the reader what to feel. Instead she lets the facts accumulate until their weight becomes difficult to ignore. A chapter on the disappearance of a particular moth from her lane is all the more affecting for being written almost entirely in the register of a field notebook: dates, temperatures, counts, and then, quietly, a column of zeros.
Not every essay succeeds. In the later chapters Holloway occasionally succumbs to the very habits she elsewhere avoids, and a meditation on a barn owl drifts into the kind of portentous generalisation, about time, loss and the human condition, that her best writing earns without ever stating. There is also a question, which the book raises but does not fully answer, about who gets to write about the countryside. Holloway acknowledges, with some candour, that she was able to spend a year walking and taking notes because she had savings and few other responsibilities; the farmers whose fields she crosses appear mostly as distant figures on tractors.
That last point touches on a wider debate. Critics have long complained that nature writing can treat landscapes as empty stages for a single sensitive narrator, airbrushing out the people who work the land. Recent years have brought welcome correctives: writing by farmers, gardeners, urban naturalists and people from communities that the older tradition seldom heard from. The genre is broader, noisier and more argumentative than it once was, and, I would suggest, healthier for it.
Does nature writing matter in an age of satellite data and climate models? Holloway's answer, implied rather than stated, is that information alone rarely changes how people behave; what changes us is the experience of having looked closely at something and come to care about it. A graph can tell you that a moth has gone. A good sentence can make you miss it. Small Weathers is not a perfect book, but it is an exacting and generous one, and it reminds us that the oldest task of the nature writer, to see clearly and to say exactly what was seen, has lost none of its urgency.