Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 74 · Debate · 731 words

Growth or Degrowth?

An ecological economist and an expert on innovation debate whether rich countries should stop pursuing economic growth, and discover that they agree on more than they expected.

This is an edited transcript of a public debate held in Bristol. The motion was 'Rich countries should stop pursuing economic growth.' Speaking for the motion was Dr Nadia Okafor, an ecological economist; speaking against it was Professor James Whitlock, who studies innovation and productivity. The chair was the broadcaster Sian Lewis.

Sian Lewis: Nadia, you have the motion. Persuade us. Nadia Okafor: Thank you. For most of the last century, growth was treated as the yardstick of progress, and for good reason: in poor societies, a bigger economy means food, medicine and schools. But in wealthy countries the link between income and wellbeing appears to have grown much weaker. Beyond a certain point, extra output seems to buy surprisingly little additional happiness, while the material throughput, the energy and raw materials flowing through the economy, keeps pressing against the limits of the planet. Degrowth, as I use the word, does not mean a recession. It means a planned, democratic reduction in the use of energy and materials in the richest nations, with the gains and losses shared fairly.

Sian Lewis: James, a planned reduction. Does that sound reasonable? James Whitlock: It sounds benign, which is not the same thing. My first objection is practical. Growth is not some arbitrary obsession; it is what pays for pensions, public health systems and the interest on government debt. Remove it, and you don't get a gentle plateau; you get a scramble over a fixed pie, and history suggests that the people who lose that scramble are rarely the comfortable ones. My second objection is that the motion misidentifies the enemy. The problem is not growth but emissions and depletion. If we can grow while cutting those, the case for degrowth falls away.

Sian Lewis: And can we? James Whitlock: The evidence is encouraging. A number of wealthy countries, including the United Kingdom, have reduced their carbon emissions substantially since 1990 while their economies have grown. That is what economists call decoupling. Renewable electricity has become dramatically cheaper, and much modern value comes from services and software, which need comparatively little material. Nadia Okafor: May I come in? James is right that some decoupling has happened, and I welcome it. But there's a difference between relative decoupling, where emissions grow more slowly than the economy, and absolute decoupling, where they actually fall. Where absolute decoupling has occurred, it has so far been far too slow to meet climate targets, and part of it reflects heavy industry moving abroad. We import the goods and offshore the emissions.

Nadia Okafor: There's also an old warning from the nineteenth century. William Stanley Jevons noticed that more efficient steam engines did not reduce Britain's use of coal; they increased it, because cheaper power found new uses. Efficiency on its own can be swallowed up by expansion. James Whitlock: Jevons is a fair warning, not an iron law. Rebound effects are real but usually partial. And I'd turn the argument round: the clean technologies that Nadia and I both want were developed in growing economies, by firms that expected expanding markets. Innovation needs investment, and investment needs confidence in the future.

Sian Lewis: Let me press you both. Nadia, isn't a 'planned reduction' a hard sell? Who votes to be poorer? Nadia Okafor: Nobody, and I'm not asking them to. I'm asking whether we measure the right things. A society can have shorter working weeks, better public transport and more time with family while consuming less stuff. Whether you call that 'poorer' depends on your accounting. Sian Lewis: James, isn't faith in future technology a kind of wishful thinking? James Whitlock: It would be, if I were proposing to wait. I'm not. I'm arguing for carbon pricing, public investment and regulation now, in tandem with growth, not instead of it.

Sian Lewis: Is there anything you agree on? Nadia Okafor: More than people might expect. We both think GDP is a poor guide to wellbeing on its own. We both want rapid cuts in emissions, and we both care about what happens to people on low incomes. James Whitlock: Where we differ is on the burden of proof. Nadia thinks growth must prove that it can be made green. I think abandoning growth must prove that it won't make the poorest worse off. Sian Lewis: Which is, I suspect, where the audience comes in. The vote is now open.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
motion/ˈməʊʃən/the statement that people argue for or against in a formal debate
yardstick/ˈjɑːdstɪk/a standard used for measuring or judging something
throughput/ˈθruːpʊt/the amount of material or energy that passes through a system
benign/bɪˈnaɪn/kind and harmless
plateau/ˈplætəʊ/a period when something stays at the same level after rising
depletion/dɪˈpliːʃən/using something up until little or none is left
decoupling/ˌdiːˈkʌplɪŋ/separating two things that used to rise and fall together
offshore/ˌɒfˈʃɔː/move work or its effects to another country
swallowed up/ˌswɒləʊd ˈʌp/completely used up or cancelled out
iron law/ˌaɪən ˈlɔː/a rule that is always true, with no exceptions
rebound effects/ˈriːbaʊnd ɪˌfekts/extra use that happens because something has become cheaper or more efficient
a hard sell/ə ˌhɑːd ˈsel/an idea that is difficult to persuade people to accept
accounting/əˈkaʊntɪŋ/the way you measure and count things such as costs and gains
wishful thinking/ˌwɪʃfəl ˈθɪŋkɪŋ/believing something because you want it to be true
in tandem with/ɪn ˈtændəm wɪð/together with; at the same time as
burden of proof/ˌbɜːdən əv ˈpruːf/the duty to show that your claim is true

Growth or Degrowth?: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.