Geologists are not, as a rule, given to drama. Their unit of time is the epoch, their patience is measured in millions of years, and their idea of a recent event is the retreat of the last ice sheets. It is all the more striking, then, that one of the most contested words of the early twenty-first century should have emerged from the earth sciences. The word is 'Anthropocene', from the Greek 'anthropos', meaning human, and it proposes something both simple and vertiginous: that humanity has become a geological force in its own right, leaving marks on the planet that will remain legible long after we are gone.
The term was popularised in 2000 by the Dutch atmospheric chemist Paul Crutzen, a Nobel laureate, who is said to have grown impatient at a conference where colleagues kept referring to the present as the Holocene, the relatively stable epoch that began roughly 11,700 years ago at the end of the last ice age. We are no longer in the Holocene, he objected; we are in the Anthropocene. The remark was off the cuff, but the idea caught on with remarkable speed, travelling from scientific journals into newspapers, museum exhibitions, novels and art galleries within a decade.
The evidence for such a claim is not hard to find. Human activity is now thought to move more rock and soil each year than all the world's rivers combined; the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is higher than at any point in human history; and species are disappearing at a rate that many biologists compare to the great extinctions of the deep past. Future geologists, should there be any, would find in the rock a thin but unmistakable layer of plastics, concrete, aluminium and the radioactive traces left by the nuclear weapons tests of the mid-twentieth century. Even the bones of the domestic chicken, now the most numerous bird on Earth, have been proposed as a marker of our age.
Yet agreeing that the Anthropocene exists is not the same as agreeing when it began, and here the debate becomes fraught. Some researchers point to the spread of farming thousands of years ago; others to the Industrial Revolution and the burning of coal; still others to the so-called Great Acceleration after 1950, when population, energy use and consumption all soared. Each choice tells a different story. To date the new epoch from the invention of agriculture is to suggest that altering the planet is simply what humans do; to date it from the steam engine is to place responsibility on particular nations and industries; to choose the 1950s is to emphasise how very recent, and how very fast, the transformation has been.
Geology has strict rules about such matters. A new division of time normally requires a golden spike: a single place where a clear change can be seen in layers of rock or sediment. After years of work, a group of scientists proposed a lake in Canada whose layered mud records the arrival of the nuclear age with unusual precision. In 2024, however, a committee of geologists voted against adding the Anthropocene to the official timescale as an epoch. For some this was a sensible act of caution; for others it was pedantry in the face of an emergency. Most agreed that the word itself would survive the vote.
Not all of the objections have come from geologists. Some critics argue that the name lumps together the whole of humanity, as though a farmer in a village without electricity bore the same responsibility as the owner of a fleet of private jets. Alternative labels have been suggested, each with its own axe to grind, placing the emphasis on a particular economic system or on the age of fossil fuels. The proliferation of rival terms is, in one sense, a measure of the concept's success. Nobody bothers to rename an idea that has failed to matter.
There is a further, subtler unease. The Anthropocene can be read as a story of human power, and power can flatter. To announce that we have become a force of nature may sound like a confession, but it can also sound like a boast, and boasts have a way of encouraging the belief that the people who broke the planet will be clever enough to fix it. Others read the same word quite differently: as a sobering reminder that our actions have consequences on a scale our ancestors could scarcely have imagined, and that with such influence comes an obligation to use it wisely.
Perhaps the best way to understand the Anthropocene, then, is not as a settled fact but as a question we are being asked. Geologists usually name epochs long after the event; we are, unusually, trying to name ours while we are still in the middle of it, which is rather like writing the review of a play before the second act has begun. What kind of layer we leave behind, and what future readers of the rock will make of it, remains, for now, in our hands.