Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 65 · Review · 796 words

Should We Colonise Space?

A critic reviews a book that questions the case for settling other worlds and asks who should decide humanity's future in space.

'Earth is the cradle of humanity, but one cannot live in the cradle for ever.' The line, usually attributed to the Russian rocket pioneer Konstantin Tsiolkovsky, has been quoted so often in writing about space travel that it has almost stopped meaning anything. Eleanor Fitch, an astrophysicist turned historian of science, opens her new book, The Cradle Problem, by taking it seriously, and then by asking, with some impatience, who exactly gets to decide when the cradle has been outgrown.

The question in her subtitle, Should We Colonise Space?, is one that most writers on the subject treat as already answered. Advocates of settlement offer three familiar arguments. The first is insurance: a species confined to one planet is vulnerable to a single catastrophe, whether an asteroid or a disaster of its own making. The second is discovery: the urge to explore, they say, is part of what makes us human. The third is economic: the resources of the Moon and the asteroids could one day relieve pressure on the Earth. Fitch gives each argument a fair hearing, which is more than some of their proponents give her side.

She is at her best on the insurance argument. Yes, she concedes, a self-sustaining settlement elsewhere would in principle protect our species against certain disasters. But the operative words are 'self-sustaining'. Mars, the most frequently proposed destination, has an atmosphere less than one per cent as dense as Earth's, made mostly of carbon dioxide; its surface is exposed to harmful radiation; a journey there takes many months. A colony that depended on regular shipments from home would be no lifeboat at all, merely a very expensive extension of the ship it was supposed to replace. 'The most hostile desert on Earth,' she writes, 'is a garden compared with the kindest place on Mars.' The line is pointed, and it lands.

Her deeper objection, though, is to the word in the title. 'Colonise' is not, she argues, a neutral term. It carries centuries of history on Earth: of lands described as empty that were nothing of the kind, and of 'discovery' that was experienced very differently by those already living there. Space, admittedly, appears to have no inhabitants to wrong. But Fitch suggests that the habits of thought remain: the assumption that what is distant is up for grabs, and that whoever arrives first should set the rules. She reminds readers that the Outer Space Treaty of 1967 forbids any nation from claiming the Moon or other celestial bodies as its own territory, and wonders, drily, how long that principle will survive the first profitable mine.

This is where some readers will part company with her. The book occasionally overplays its hand, treating every rocket launch as the opening chapter of an empire. Enthusiasts for exploration are not all conquistadors in spacesuits; many are scientists who simply want to know whether life has ever existed anywhere else, a question of almost unbearable importance. Fitch knows this, since her own early career was spent studying the atmospheres of distant planets, and her scepticism is at its weakest when it shades into suspicion of curiosity itself.

What saves the book is its final section, which is less a verdict than a set of conditions. If humans are to live beyond Earth, Fitch argues, the decision should be made by more than a handful of wealthy nations and companies; the benefits and risks should be shared; scientific sites should be protected as we protect places of special value on Earth; and no settlement should ever be presented as an escape hatch that excuses neglect of the only planet known to support us. That last condition is the book's real thesis. The danger of space colonisation, in her account, is not that it will fail but that the dream of it will make us careless at home.

Is she right? On the evidence of this book, the honest answer is that it is too early to say, and Fitch would probably accept that. Her achievement is to reframe the debate: not 'can we?', which is an engineering question, nor even 'should we?', which invites easy slogans on both sides, but 'on what terms, and who decides?' It is a less thrilling question than the ones on the posters at science museums. It is also, for a reader in the twenty-first century, the right one.

The Cradle Problem is not a perfect book. Its middle chapters are repetitive, and its tone, though usually measured, sometimes tips into the sermon. But it is a necessary one, and its central image stays with you. A cradle, Fitch points out in her closing pages, is not only something you grow out of. It is also something you are supposed to look after for whoever comes next.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
a fair hearing/ə ˌfeə ˈhɪərɪŋ/a proper chance to be listened to and judged fairly
proponents/prəˈpəʊnənts/people who support an idea
self-sustaining/ˌself səˈsteɪnɪŋ/able to continue without help from outside
operative/ˈɒpərətɪv/most important; the one that really matters
pointed/ˈpɔɪntɪd/(of a remark) sharp and clearly aimed at a target
up for grabs/ˌʌp fə ˈɡræbz/available for anyone to take
celestial bodies/səˌlestiəl ˈbɒdiz/natural objects in space, such as moons, planets and asteroids
drily/ˈdraɪli/in a quietly humorous way, without seeming to joke
part company/ˌpɑːt ˈkʌmpəni/stop agreeing with someone
overplays its hand/ˌəʊvəˈpleɪz ɪts ˈhænd/pushes its argument too far and so weakens it
conquistadors/kɒnˈkwɪstədɔːz/the Spanish soldiers who conquered parts of the Americas in the 1500s
scepticism/ˈskeptɪsɪzəm/an attitude of doubt about claims
shades into/ˈʃeɪdz ˌɪntuː/gradually changes into something else
escape hatch/ɪˈskeɪp hætʃ/a way out of a difficult situation
thesis/ˈθiːsɪs/the main argument of a book or essay
reframe/ˌriːˈfreɪm/present something in a new way so people see it differently
sermon/ˈsɜːmən/a speech, often religious, that tells people how they should behave

Should We Colonise Space?: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.