In 1971 the economist and psychologist Herbert Simon made an observation that has aged better than almost anything else written about computers in that decade. A wealth of information, he noted, creates a poverty of attention. Half a century later, his remark has hardened into an industry slogan. We are told that we live in an 'attention economy', that our eyes are the commodity being traded, and that every app on our phones is engaged in a silent auction for the next few seconds of our lives. The metaphor is so ubiquitous that it is easy to forget it is a metaphor at all.
I do not wish to dismiss it. As a description of how much of the internet is paid for, it is accurate enough: services that cost nothing at the point of use are financed by advertising, and advertising is priced by the number of people who look at it and for how long. Anyone who has picked up a phone to check the weather and surfaced, twenty minutes later, from a stream of videos about restoring antique furniture will recognise the pull of systems designed to keep us looking. To call attention a resource is to say something true: it is finite, it is valuable, and others are prepared to compete for it.
Yet metaphors do not merely describe; they also smuggle in assumptions. If attention is a currency, then the sensible response to its scarcity is budgeting. Hence the cottage industry of advice on 'digital detoxes', screen-time limits and apps that, with no apparent irony, use notifications to remind us to look at our phones less. The underlying picture is of a rational individual with a fixed sum to spend, who merely needs better accounting. It is a tidy picture, and I suspect it is mistaken in at least two respects.
The first is that attention is not something we possess before we spend it. William James, writing in 1890, put the point with characteristic bluntness: 'My experience is what I agree to attend to.' On this view, attention is less like money in a wallet than like the lens through which a world appears at all. What we notice shapes what we care about, and what we care about shapes who we become. To lose an afternoon to an endless feed is therefore not quite like losing a ten-pound note. It is closer to having someone else edit a small portion of one's life.
The second mistake is to treat the problem as purely private. When a library is full of people silently reading, each reader's concentration is supported by everyone else's. A classroom, a concert hall and even a quiet carriage on a train are shared arrangements that make sustained attention easier for all. Seen in this light, attention has something in common with clean air: it is a condition that communities can protect or erode, not merely a sum that individuals manage well or badly. Telling people to try harder while their surroundings are engineered against them is rather like advising someone to breathe more carefully on a polluted street.
None of this means that technology is the villain of the story. The same devices that fragment our afternoons also allow a teenager in a small town to follow a lecture from a university on the other side of the world, or a grandmother to watch her grandson's first steps as they happen. The tool is not the problem so much as the incentives behind its design. A notification sent because something genuinely needs us is a service; a notification sent because our attention has been sold in advance is something else.
What, then, should we do? Individual habits still matter – I have moved my own phone out of the bedroom, and my sleep is grateful – but they are a starting point rather than a solution. Schools that create long, uninterrupted periods for reading, workplaces that do not expect replies to messages at midnight, and designers who measure success by whether users leave satisfied rather than by how long they stay, would all be treating attention as a shared good rather than a raw material to be extracted.
The French philosopher Simone Weil once described attention as the rarest and purest form of generosity. It is a striking claim, and it points to something the economic metaphor cannot capture. When we give someone our full attention, we are not spending a resource; we are offering a kind of recognition. Perhaps the real cost of a distracted age is not lost productivity but lost presence – the friend half-listened to, the book half-read, the walk taken with eyes on a screen. Attention may be scarce, but it is not merely a resource. It is, in a quite literal sense, where we live.