This is an edited transcript of an episode of 'Thinking Aloud', a weekly podcast about ideas. The host, Owen Pritchard, is joined by Dr Saoirse Kelleher, a bioethicist at a university in Belfast, and Dr Daniel Ashworth, a philosopher who writes about technology and the body.
Owen: Let's begin with a confession. I've had two cups of coffee this morning, and I'm wearing glasses. Am I an enhanced human? Daniel: In a modest sense, yes, and I think that's exactly the right place to start. Humans have always used tools to extend themselves: spectacles, vaccines, reading, even education. The idea that there's a pure, unadulterated human nature which enhancement would corrupt doesn't survive much contact with history. Saoirse: I'd agree with half of that. Of course we've always extended ourselves. But 'we've always done something a bit like this' isn't the same as 'this is fine'. The question is where the differences lie, not whether there are similarities.
Owen: Philosophers often distinguish between therapy and enhancement: treating an illness versus making a healthy person better than normal. Does that distinction hold up? Saoirse: It's leaky, but it's useful. Restoring someone's sight is plainly different from giving a healthy person the ability to see in the dark. The trouble is that 'normal' is a moving target. A drug that slows memory loss in older age might count as therapy for one person and enhancement for another. Daniel: Which is why I'd rather drop the distinction altogether and ask a simpler question: does the intervention make someone's life go better, by their own lights, without harming others? If it does, the burden of proof should lie with those who want to forbid it.
Owen: That 'without harming others' is doing a lot of work, isn't it? Saoirse: An enormous amount. Think about what economists call positional goods: things whose value depends on having more than other people. If a memory-boosting drug helps one student, that's an advantage. If everyone in the class takes it, nobody is ahead, but everyone is now paying for it and taking whatever risks it carries. People may feel they have no real choice. That kind of creeping pressure is what worries me most: not a dramatic dystopia, but a world in which opting out quietly becomes a luxury few can afford.
Daniel: That's a serious point, and I don't want to brush it aside. But we already live with that pressure. Parents pay for tutoring, music lessons, better schools. We don't ban tutoring; we try to make it more widely available. If an enhancement were safe and genuinely useful, the fair response might be to make it accessible to everyone rather than to forbid it to anyone. Saoirse: Unless the problem is the arms race itself. Some competitions simply stop making sense once one side can change the rules of the body. That's why sport bans certain substances: not because they don't work, but because they turn a contest of skill and training into a contest of pharmacy.
Owen: There's a more personal objection, isn't there, that enhanced achievements are somehow less authentic? Daniel: I'm suspicious of that one. Nobody says a novelist's book is less hers because she wrote it with a word processor rather than a quill. Saoirse: True, but there's a reason we admire effort. A runner who trains for years tells a different story from one who takes a pill. Some philosophers describe life as partly a gift, and argue that humility about what we're given is a moral attitude worth keeping, even when we're able to change it. I don't think that settles every case, but I'd hate to lose it entirely in the rush to improve.
Owen: Is there anything you'd both rule out? Daniel: Anything done to people without their consent, and that includes children, who can't consent to changes that would follow them for life. I'm a cheerleader for choice, not for compulsion. Saoirse: On that we agree completely. And I'd add: we should be very wary of anyone who claims to know what the 'best' human looks like. Past attempts to answer that question with confidence have ended badly. Diversity in bodies and minds is not a defect to be engineered away. Daniel: I'd sign up to that. Enhancement, if it means anything good, should mean more ways of flourishing, not fewer. Owen: A rare moment of consensus on this podcast. Let's leave it there.