Is the screen the enemy of poetry or its unexpected ally? After years of gloomy predictions, poetry readership appears by several measures to have grown, much of it among young people who discover poems on their phones. Yet some critics fear that what is flourishing is a diluted form, shaped by the demands of the scroll. Daniel Okafor chaired a debate in Glasgow between the poet Isla Mackenzie, who first found an audience online, and Dr Hugh Bramwell, who teaches poetry at a university in Leeds.
Daniel: Hugh, you've written that the screen is changing poetry for the worse. Why? Hugh: Not for the worse, exactly – I'd say it's changing what we reward. A poem on a feed has perhaps two seconds to stop a thumb. That favours the instantly relatable: a single feeling, stated plainly, ideally in a line you can share. There's nothing wrong with that. But a great deal of poetry works the other way. It withholds. It asks you to read it three times before it opens. I worry that we're training readers to expect the first kind and to give up on the second. Isla: I understand the worry, but I think it underestimates readers. Nobody's first poem is a difficult one. Mine was a short poem on a poster on the London Underground, when I was fourteen. It took me ten seconds to read and a year to stop thinking about.
Isla: The screen is just a new version of that poster. The question is what happens next. In my experience, people who start with short poems online go looking for more, and some of them end up reading Emily Dickinson or Shakespeare's sonnets. A gateway isn't a cage. Hugh: That's a fair point, and I hope you're right. But a gateway only works if there's something on the other side that looks worth the walk. Brevity in itself isn't the problem; Dickinson's poems are often tiny. Her brevity is compression, though – an enormous amount packed into a small space. What I see online is often brevity as dilution: very little, spread thinly over a few lines with a lot of white space. Daniel: Isla, is that unfair?
Isla: Partly fair. There's a lot of weak writing online – but there was a lot of weak writing in print too; we've just forgotten it, because time is a ruthless editor. I'd also say the screen has given us things print never could. Poets can perform their work, so you hear the rhythm and breath of it. People in places with no bookshop and no poetry society can find a community. And the old gatekeepers – a handful of editors and prize committees – no longer decide alone who gets read. Hugh: I'll grant you the gatekeepers. Though I'd point out that an algorithm is a gatekeeper too, and a less accountable one. At least an editor can be argued with.
Daniel: What about attention itself? We're often told that screens are shortening it. Hugh: That's my deeper anxiety. Poetry is a technology for slowing down. The line break, the stanza, the rhyme – they all make you pause. A medium designed to keep you moving is at odds with that. Isla: And yet people do stop. I've watched a poem about a grandmother's hands being read, reread and copied out by hand by thousands of strangers. That isn't distraction. Poetry has always been portable – that's why so much of it was memorised long before it was ever written down. A phone is just the latest pocket. Hugh: A lovely line. I may steal it.
By the end, the two had found more common ground than the evening's title suggested. Both agreed that the danger lies less in the screen than in complacency: in readers who never move beyond the familiar, and in critics who dismiss a new audience without listening to it. As Isla Mackenzie put it, quoting Alexander Pope with a smile, the best poems still offer 'what oft was thought, but ne'er so well expressed' – whatever surface they happen to appear on.