Every autumn, with the predictability of falling leaves, the literary world gathers in a grand hall to discover which novel is officially the best of the year. Cameras are trained on six nervous writers; an envelope is opened; one face lights up and five arrange themselves into expressions of gracious delight. By the following morning, the winner's sales have soared, the bookshops have rearranged their windows, and a vague sense has spread that a question of taste has been settled. It has not, of course. But the ceremony is so persuasive that we forget to ask what, exactly, it has measured.
Let me be clear: I am not against prizes. They do real good. A prize can rescue a fine book from obscurity, give a struggling writer a year of freedom, and persuade thousands of people who rarely buy fiction to try something new. For small publishers in particular, a place on a shortlist can be the difference between survival and closure. 'We sold more copies in the fortnight after the shortlist than in the whole previous year,' a publisher at a small press in Norwich told me. That is not a trivial achievement, and anyone who sneers at it should try running a small press.
The trouble begins when we mistake the result for a verdict. A prize is the outcome of a particular conversation among a particular group of people – often five judges, reading well over a hundred books in a few months – and, like all conversations, it is shaped by compromise. Graham Whitlock, a retired editor who once chaired a judging panel, is disarmingly frank about this. 'The book everyone loves rarely wins,' he says. 'The book that wins is often the one nobody hates. Strong books divide people, and a panel tends to settle on the consensus candidate.' The prize, in other words, may reward the least controversial excellence rather than the greatest.
History offers some sobering correctives. The Nobel Prize in Literature was first awarded in 1901; Leo Tolstoy, still alive and writing for the best part of a decade afterwards, never received it. Many writers now regarded as central to the literary tradition were overlooked by the prizes of their day, while some celebrated winners have quietly disappeared from the shelves. This is not a scandal. It is simply what happens when a judgement made in a single season is asked to stand for posterity. Literary reputations are settled, if they are ever settled, over decades, by readers who were not in the room.
There is a subtler cost, too. Prizes create incentives, and incentives shape behaviour. Publishers learn which kinds of novel tend to be shortlisted – serious in subject, ambitious in scope, ideally historical – and adjust their lists accordingly. Writers, consciously or not, may do the same. Comic novels, genre fiction and quiet domestic stories, however brilliantly done, are rarely seen as 'prize books', and so a whole range of excellence becomes less visible. A culture that looks to a few annual awards to tell it what matters risks narrowing its own taste.
Then there is the spectacle itself. The language of prizes is borrowed from sport: shortlists and longlists, favourites and outsiders, winners and – by implication – losers. Yet novels are not racing against one another. A book does not become worse because a different book was chosen, though the ceremony makes it feel that way. Several writers have described the odd experience of being congratulated for being shortlisted and commiserated with for not winning, sometimes within the same hour, about the same unchanged book.
What, then, is to be done? Abolishing prizes would be foolish and, given their benefits, unkind. A better approach is to take them less literally. We might treat a shortlist as an invitation rather than a ranking – six books that a thoughtful group found worth arguing about. We might pay as much attention to the books that nearly made it as to the winner. And we might remember that the most valuable literary judgement is the one each reader makes alone, at the kitchen table, with no cameras present.
Prizes are at their best when they start conversations, and at their worst when they end them. The envelope, after all, contains only a name. The real verdict is still being written, slowly, by everyone who reads.