Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 59 · Feature · 653 words

Performance and Presence

A feature, built around a solo cello concert in a Yorkshire chapel, asking why live performance still matters when almost any recording is available instantly.

Shortly before eight o’clock on a wet Thursday evening, about two hundred people file into a converted chapel in Hebden Bridge to hear a cellist play Bach. Almost all of them have the same music on their phones, performed by some of the most celebrated musicians alive, available at any moment for less than the price of a sandwich. Yet here they are, having bought tickets, found parking and left warm houses, to sit on hard pews and listen to a single woman with a single instrument. Why do we still bother?

The question is older than streaming. In an essay written in the mid-1930s, the German critic Walter Benjamin argued that mechanical reproduction, by which he meant photography, film and sound recording, was stripping works of art of their ‘aura’: the unique presence of an object in a particular time and place. A copy, however faithful, could be anywhere; the original could only be here. Benjamin was not simply lamenting this loss. He also believed that reproduction could free art from ritual and bring it to far wider audiences. But his word has stuck, and it names something that many concert-goers recognise without being able to define.

At the other extreme stands the Canadian pianist Glenn Gould, who in 1964, at the height of his fame, gave up public performance altogether and devoted the rest of his career to the recording studio. Gould argued that the studio, where a performance could be assembled from many takes, allowed a deeper and more thoughtful interpretation than the nervous, one-off conditions of the concert platform. He even predicted that the public concert would eventually disappear. It has not.

After the concert I spoke to the cellist, Ruth Adeyemi, in the chapel’s cramped back room. Interviewer: Why does the live version still matter, when listeners can hear a ‘perfect’ recording at home? Adeyemi: Because perfection isn’t really what people come for. A recording is a finished object. A concert is an event that hasn’t happened yet. Everyone in the room, including me, knows it could go wrong, and that precariousness sharpens the attention. People listen differently when there’s something at stake. Interviewer: Does the audience change the way you play? Adeyemi: Enormously. You can feel a room. There’s a particular quality of silence when people are really with you, a sort of held breath, and it changes my phrasing. I’ll take more time over a pause if I sense they’ll wait with me. In the studio there’s no one to wait with.

Interviewer: Gould would say that’s exactly the problem: the music is being bent by the crowd. Adeyemi: He’d have a point. Some of my live performances are less polished than my recordings, and I’d never pretend otherwise. But music was a social art for thousands of years before it was a recorded one. I think of a concert as a conversation in which only one person happens to be speaking aloud.

Researchers have begun to offer some support for Adeyemi’s intuition. Studies suggest that people attending a live performance together can show a degree of shared physical response, with heart rates and breathing tending to move in loose synchrony during moments of tension and release. The research is young, and its findings should not be overstated, but it hints at why a concert can feel less like consumption and more like communion.

None of this makes recordings the enemy. Most of the people in the chapel first heard these suites through headphones, and it was the recording that brought them here. Perhaps the two forms are best understood not as rivals but as different kinds of experience: one a book that can be reread whenever we like, the other a conversation that will never quite happen again. As the audience shuffles out into the rain, several people stop to thank Adeyemi in person. Nobody, as far as I know, has ever thanked a download.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
file into/ˈfaɪl ˌɪntuː/walk into a place one after another, in a line
celebrated/ˈseləbreɪtɪd/famous and admired
pews/pjuːz/long wooden seats in a church or chapel
reproduction/ˌriːprəˈdʌkʃən/making copies of something
aura/ˈɔːrə/a special quality or feeling that seems to surround someone or something
lamenting/ləˈmentɪŋ/expressing sadness or regret about something
interpretation/ɪnˌtɜːprɪˈteɪʃn/a performer’s personal way of playing or understanding a piece
precariousness/prɪˈkeəriəsnəs/the state of being uncertain and likely to go wrong
at stake/ət ˈsteɪk/that can be won or lost; at risk
phrasing/ˈfreɪzɪŋ/the way a musician shapes and groups the notes of a melody
polished/ˈpɒlɪʃt/perfect and smooth, with no mistakes
intuition/ˌɪntjuˈɪʃn/a feeling that something is true, without proof
synchrony/ˈsɪŋkrəni/happening at the same time and speed
overstated/ˌəʊvəˈsteɪtɪd/described as bigger or more important than it really is
communion/kəˈmjuːniən/a feeling of sharing something deeply with other people
shuffles/ˈʃʌfəlz/walks slowly without lifting the feet much

Performance and Presence: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.