Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 58 · Essay · 685 words

In Praise of Ugliness

An essay arguing that ugliness deserves a closer look, from The Rite of Spring and Brutalist concrete to Japanese repaired pottery and a Belfast sculptor.

Beauty has never lacked defenders. Poets praise it, philosophers define it and whole industries promise to sell it. Ugliness, by contrast, is usually treated as a simple absence, a failure that needs no theory, only correction. Yet the more closely one looks, the less simple it becomes. The Italian writer Umberto Eco, having published a history of beauty, followed it in 2007 with a companion volume on ugliness, and suggested that it was in many ways the richer subject. Beauty, he observed, tends towards a certain sameness, while ugliness is endlessly varied. There are, it seems, many more ways to be strange than to be perfect.

Consider how often the art we now cherish was first greeted with revulsion. When Stravinsky’s The Rite of Spring had its premiere in Paris in 1913, its clashing harmonies and pounding rhythms provoked such an uproar in the theatre that the dancers could barely hear the orchestra. In the nineteenth century, critics dismissed many Impressionist canvases as daubs, unfinished sketches that no serious painter would dare to exhibit. Today both are staples of concert halls, galleries and greeting cards. One generation’s eyesore is frequently the next generation’s treasure, which ought to make us a little more modest about our own verdicts.

Architecture offers the most visible examples. The concrete buildings of the post-war decades, often grouped under the label Brutalism, were for many years treated as shorthand for everything that had gone wrong with modern Britain: grey, stained and forbidding. Some were demolished to general relief. The name, incidentally, has nothing to do with brutality; it comes from the French béton brut, meaning ‘raw concrete’. A number of these buildings have since been protected by law, and a new generation of admirers photographs their rough surfaces and bold geometry with something close to devotion. The buildings themselves have hardly changed. What has changed is the eye that looks at them.

Other traditions have long found value in what Western taste might call flaws. The Japanese way of seeing often described as wabi-sabi prizes asymmetry, roughness and the marks of age: a tea bowl with an uneven rim, a wooden beam darkened by generations of hands. A related practice, kintsugi, repairs broken pottery with lacquer mixed with powdered gold, so that the cracks become the most striking feature of the object rather than something to disguise. The message is not that damage is good, but that an object’s history is part of its worth.

The sculptor Niamh Gallagher, who works with scrap metal and salvaged timber in a studio outside Belfast, puts it more plainly. ‘Pretty is easy,’ she says. ‘Pretty is what you get when nobody takes a risk. The things that stop me in my tracks are usually a bit awkward, a bit wrong. They make me ask why, and that question is where art starts.’ Her own pieces, assembled from rusting gates and warped boards, divide visitors sharply. Some find them unsettling; others return to them again and again. Gallagher regards both reactions as a success. What she fears is indifference.

None of this means that every ugly thing is secretly beautiful, or that standards are meaningless. Some buildings really are badly made, and some music really is careless. The point is subtler. Ugliness can be a sign of neglect, but it can also be a sign of honesty, of a refusal to flatter. A portrait that shows wrinkles, a song that lets a voice crack, a city that keeps its awkward old warehouses: each declines the easy comfort of polish in favour of something truer to experience.

There is also a moral dimension, though it must be handled with care. A culture that worships a narrow ideal of beauty tends, sooner or later, to apply it to people, and to judge harshly those who do not fit. Learning to look patiently at things we first find unattractive, to ask what they are doing rather than simply recoil, is good practice for looking kindly at one another. In that sense, a little praise of ugliness may be less a perverse taste than a quiet form of generosity.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
revulsion/rɪˈvʌlʃən/a very strong feeling of dislike, almost disgust
daubs/dɔːbz/paintings done carelessly or without skill
staples/ˈsteɪpəlz/basic, regular parts of something that are always there
eyesore/ˈaɪsɔː/something, especially a building, that is very unpleasant to look at
verdicts/ˈvɜːdɪkts/final judgements or opinions about something
Brutalism/ˈbruːtəlɪzəm/a style of architecture with large, plain buildings of rough concrete
shorthand/ˈʃɔːthænd/here: a quick, simple symbol for a bigger idea
wabi-sabi/ˌwɑːbi ˈsɑːbi/a Japanese idea of beauty in simple, imperfect and ageing things
asymmetry/eɪˈsɪmətri/when two sides of something are not the same shape or size
lacquer/ˈlækə/a liquid that dries to a hard, shiny surface
warped/wɔːpt/bent or twisted out of its proper shape
unsettling/ʌnˈsetlɪŋ/making you feel slightly worried or uncomfortable
indifference/ɪnˈdɪfrəns/not caring or having any feeling about something
neglect/nɪˈɡlekt/not looking after something properly
flatter/ˈflætə/make someone or something seem better or more attractive than they really are
polish/ˈpɒlɪʃ/here: a smooth, perfect, finished quality
recoil/rɪˈkɔɪl/move back suddenly because you dislike or fear something
perverse/pəˈvɜːs/strange and unreasonable, the opposite of what most people would expect

In Praise of Ugliness: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.