Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 57 · Symposium · 680 words

Can Machines Make Art?

A composer, a philosopher and a painter debate whether machines can be creative, who deserves the credit and what is at stake for human artists.

The following is an edited transcript of a symposium held at a literary festival in Bath, part of a series on the arts in the twenty-first century. The chair, Imogen Hale, was joined by the composer Tobias Wren, who has used generative software in several recent works; the philosopher Dr Anjali Rao; and Marcus Bell, a painter and curator based in Glasgow.

Hale: Let’s begin bluntly. Can a machine make art? Rao: It depends on whether you mean ‘produce something that looks like art’ or ‘be an artist’. The first is now trivially true. Systems trained on vast collections of images and recordings can turn out pictures and melodies of astonishing fluency. The second is far harder. We usually think of art as an act of communication: someone has something to say and finds a form for it. I’m not convinced there is anyone at home in these systems with anything to say. Wren: With respect, that’s a rather romantic picture. Plenty of music has been written to a deadline by people who had nothing in particular to say that morning. The meaning arrived in the making, and in the listening.

Bell: I’d add that the question isn’t new. In 1843 Ada Lovelace, writing about Charles Babbage’s Analytical Engine, suggested that such a machine might one day compose elaborate pieces of music. But she was careful to add that it could not originate anything; it could only do what we knew how to order it to do. We’ve been arguing about her caveat for nearly two centuries. Hale: And has the argument moved on? Bell: Somewhat. Harold Cohen, a British-born painter, spent decades from the early 1970s developing a drawing program he called AARON. Cohen never claimed that AARON was an artist in its own right. He saw it as an extraordinarily elaborate brush, an extension of his own sensibility. That strikes me as a more honest way to describe most of what we see today.

Wren: That’s roughly how I work. For my last piece for string quartet, the software generated hundreds of short phrases overnight. Ninety-nine per cent of them were dross. My job was to listen, select, cut and connect. If anything, the machine made me more of a composer, not less, because it forced me to explain to myself why one phrase moved me and another left me cold. Rao: But notice what you’ve just said. The judgement, the being moved, was yours. The software supplied raw material, much as a quarry supplies stone. Nobody credits the quarry with the cathedral. Wren: Touché. Though a quarry doesn’t surprise you. This did, now and then.

Hale: Let me put the audience’s worry. Many people feel that something is being taken from them, whether jobs, or skills, or simply the dignity of making things. Bell: I take that seriously. Illustrators and session musicians are already feeling the pressure, and it would be glib to tell them that every new technology creates as many opportunities as it destroys. There are also unresolved questions about consent. These systems learned from the work of real artists, most of whom were never asked. Rao: That, to my mind, is the most urgent issue, more urgent than the metaphysical one. Whether or not a machine can be creative, people certainly can be exploited.

Hale: So where does all this leave the ordinary art lover? Rao: Perhaps with a renewed sense of what we value. If a flawless landscape can be produced in seconds, flawlessness ceases to impress. What may matter more is evidence of a particular life: the hesitation in a brushstroke, the risk in a live performance. Wren: Or we may simply learn to listen differently, as audiences learned to look differently when photography arrived and painters stopped competing with it. Painting didn’t die. It went somewhere new. Bell: I’d like to think the most interesting work will come from artists who treat these tools neither as oracles nor as enemies, but as collaborators whose limitations are as instructive as their gifts. Hale: On that note of cautious optimism, thank you all.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
symposium/sɪmˈpəʊziəm/a formal meeting where experts discuss a subject
generative/ˈdʒenərətɪv/able to produce new things, such as pictures, text or music, by itself
bluntly/ˈblʌntli/directly and honestly, without trying to be polite
trivially/ˈtrɪviəli/so obviously that it is hardly worth saying
fluency/ˈfluːənsi/the quality of being smooth, easy and skilful
romantic/rəʊˈmæntɪk/here: based on beautiful ideas rather than on how things really are
originate/əˈrɪdʒɪneɪt/create something new for the first time
caveat/ˈkæviæt/a warning or a condition that limits what has just been said
sensibility/ˌsensəˈbɪləti/a person’s way of feeling and judging, especially in art
dross/drɒs/rubbish; something of very low quality
raw material/ˌrɔː məˈtɪəriəl/basic material that is used to make something else
touché/ˈtuːʃeɪ/said to admit that someone has made a good point against you
glib/ɡlɪb/said too easily and confidently, without enough thought
metaphysical/ˌmetəˈfɪzɪkəl/about deep, abstract questions of what things really are
exploited/ɪkˈsplɔɪtɪd/treated unfairly so that someone else gets the benefit
oracles/ˈɒrəkəlz/people or things believed to give wise answers that cannot be questioned
instructive/ɪnˈstrʌktɪv/teaching you something useful

Can Machines Make Art?: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.