The philosopher Miriam Ashcombe taught at a university in York for almost thirty years before turning her attention to a rather younger audience: she now runs philosophy sessions in primary schools across Yorkshire. Her latest book, The Patient Question, has been described as both a defence of her subject and a gentle confession of its limits. We spoke in her cluttered study, surrounded by unanswered letters and a great many plants.
Interviewer: Let me begin with the question you must be tired of hearing. What is philosophy actually for? Ashcombe: I'm not tired of it at all; it's a perfectly good philosophical question, and the fact that people ask it so indignantly tells you something. We don't demand that music justify itself, or friendship. But I'll give you a straight answer. Philosophy is the habit of noticing what we take for granted. Every argument, every law, every scientific theory rests on assumptions that nobody stops to examine. Philosophy is the stopping. Interviewer: That sounds rather like a recipe for never getting anything done. Ashcombe: It would be, if everyone did it all the time. Nobody should philosophise about the brakes while driving. But a society in which no one ever stops is like a car with no one checking the map. You may be making excellent progress in entirely the wrong direction.
Interviewer: Your critics say philosophers have been arguing about the same questions for two and a half thousand years without settling any of them. Isn't that a fairly damning record? Ashcombe: It would be, if settling questions were the point. I'd put it differently. When a question in philosophy is finally answered, it tends to leave the family and set up house elsewhere: physics, psychology, logic and economics all began as branches of philosophy. So the subject is left, by definition, with the questions that remain stubbornly open. Judging it by its unsolved problems is a little like judging a hospital by the fact that everyone in it is ill. Interviewer: That's rather convenient, though, isn't it? Ashcombe: (laughs) Rather too convenient, perhaps. I'll concede that we have sometimes hidden behind it. There's a kind of philosophy that mistakes obscurity for depth, and I've written my share of it. If a reader can't follow an argument, the fault is usually the writer's.
Interviewer: Tell me about the schools. Why children? Ashcombe: Because they haven't yet learnt to be embarrassed by big questions. A seven-year-old in Harrogate once asked me whether a river is still the same river if all the water in it has changed. That is, almost word for word, a puzzle that troubled the ancient Greeks. Adults have usually been taught to file such questions under 'silly'. Children haven't, so they're formidable company. Interviewer: But do they actually learn anything, or is it just pleasant conversation? Ashcombe: Both, and I don't think pleasant conversation is a small thing. What they learn, above all, is to disagree without falling out. In a good session a child will say, 'I disagree with Amira because…' and then give a reason. That small word 'because' is where civilisation begins. Teachers tell me the habit spills over into the playground, though I'd be wary of claiming too much. The research is encouraging rather than conclusive.
Interviewer: Your book's title suggests that patience is a virtue in thinking. In an age of instant answers, isn't that a hard sell? Ashcombe: Terribly hard. We have built machines that will answer almost anything in seconds, and I'm genuinely grateful for them. But an answer is only as good as the question that produced it, and questions need time to ripen. The danger isn't that we'll know too much; it's that we'll stop noticing which questions we never thought to ask. Interviewer: So you're not a pessimist about technology. Ashcombe: I'm a pessimist about complacency, which is a different thing. Technology simply makes complacency more comfortable.
Interviewer: Finally, has philosophy made you happier? Ashcombe: That's an unfair question to put to a philosopher; you know I'll want to define happiness first. (pause) Let's say it has made me less certain and more curious, and on most days I'd count that as a fair exchange. The ancient sceptics believed that suspending judgement brought peace of mind. I've never quite managed the peace. But I've grown rather fond of the suspense.