This is an edited transcript of a debate held at a public library in Bristol as part of a series called 'Ideas Worth Arguing About'. The chair, Ruth Kendal, invited two speakers to consider whether social media platforms are, in any meaningful sense, the public square of our time: Owen Adebayo, a historian of the press, and Clara Haverford, who writes about technology and design.
Kendal: Owen, you've argued that the comparison holds. Make your case. Adebayo: Gladly. Ask yourself where, today, a citizen goes to hear the news, argue about it and be heard by strangers. For most of history the answer was a physical place: the forum, the market cross, the coffee house, the town hall steps. Those places were never perfect, and they were never open to everyone, but they shared a function. They were where private people became a public. If that function has migrated online, and I think it plainly has, then the metaphor isn't decoration. It's description. Platforms may be privately owned, but so were many coffee houses. What matters is the role a space plays, not the name on the deeds.
Kendal: Clara, you're unconvinced. Haverford: I'm unconvinced by the metaphor, not by Owen's history, which is excellent. A square is a place you simply stand in. Nobody arranges the crowd around you according to what will keep you there longest. Social media is closer to a shopping centre designed by a very clever architect, one who rearranges the corridors every night depending on where you lingered yesterday. When we call that a square, we flatter it. We borrow the dignity of an old civic idea and lend it to something that works on quite different principles. Adebayo: But the coffee house owner also wanted customers to stay and buy another cup. Haverford: Of course. But he couldn't decide which conversation you overheard. That's a difference in kind, not merely in degree.
Kendal: Does the label actually matter? Aren't we just arguing about words? Adebayo: Words shape expectations. If we think of these spaces as public, we start to ask public questions: who gets to speak, who is drowned out, what we owe one another there. Those are good questions to be asking. Haverford: I agree they're good questions. My worry is that the metaphor answers them too quickly. If it's a square, then the obvious remedy for any problem is more speech, more openness, more access, because that's what squares are for. But some of the difficulties online come precisely from the design – from what is amplified and what is buried. You can't fix a design problem with a slogan about freedom, however noble the slogan.
Kendal: Let's take a question from the floor. Audience member: I'm sixteen. Most of my friends don't think of social media as a square or a shopping centre. It's just where everyone is. Does it matter what adults call it? Haverford: That's a wonderfully deflating question, and I mean that as a compliment. You're right that for most people it's simply the background of life, like the weather. But that's exactly why it's worth describing carefully. The things we stop noticing are the things that shape us most. Adebayo: I'd add that 'where everyone is' is almost a definition of a public square. You've made my argument rather better than I did.
Kendal: As we close, is there anything you agree on? Haverford: More than the poster suggested. We both think people deserve spaces where they can disagree well. We both think those spaces should be understood, not just used. Adebayo: And we both think the old squares were worth something. Where we differ is whether today's platforms have inherited their role or merely their vocabulary. I'm hopeful they can grow into the part. Clara suspects they're wearing a costume. Haverford: A very convincing costume. That's what worries me.