On a grey morning in Eyam, a village in the hills of Derbyshire, a retired schoolteacher named Margaret Lowe stands beside a low wall and points to a stone with a hollow in its top. 'Coins went in there,' she says, 'in vinegar, to clean them. People from the next village left food; the villagers left payment. Nobody crossed the line.' The stone is one of the boundary markers of a remarkable episode. In 1665 and 1666, when plague reached the village, reputedly in a consignment of cloth from London, the villagers, led by their rector, agreed to cut themselves off rather than risk carrying the disease to neighbouring towns. Many of them did not survive. Their choice is remembered every summer, and the village has become a place of quiet pilgrimage.
Eyam's ordeal came near the end of a long history. The great pandemic known as the Black Death had swept across Europe three centuries earlier, between 1347 and 1351, killing perhaps a third or more of the continent's population; some estimates put the figure closer to half. Its cause, the bacterium Yersinia pestis, was not identified until 1894, and for most of the intervening centuries people explained the disease in terms of bad air, the movements of the planets or divine displeasure. Plague returned in waves for more than three hundred years.
What interests many historians today is less the catastrophe itself than its long aftermath. With so many people gone, labour became scarce, and in much of western Europe those who survived found they could demand higher wages and better terms. In England, the authorities tried to hold wages at their old levels with the Statute of Labourers of 1351, with limited success. Some historians link the resentments of this period to the Peasants' Revolt of 1381; others warn against drawing too straight a line. 'It's tempting to tell a neat story in which the plague freed the peasants,' says Dr Samuel Kerr, an economic historian I spoke to in Sheffield. 'The reality was slower and patchier. In parts of eastern Europe, over the following centuries, landowners actually tightened their grip. The plague didn't decide the outcome; it changed the bargaining power of the people involved, and they did the rest.'
The plague also left its mark on institutions and on language. The word 'quarantine' comes from the Italian 'quaranta giorni', meaning forty days, the period that ships arriving from infected ports were made to wait, in Venice and other Mediterranean ports, before passengers and goods could come ashore. Boards of health, isolation hospitals and the careful recording of deaths all grew, in part, out of centuries of living with the disease. 'Modern public health has very deep roots,' Kerr says. 'Many of its basic ideas were worked out by people who had no idea what a bacterium was.'
Culture, too, bears the imprint. Giovanni Boccaccio set his 'Decameron' in 1348, among a group of young people who leave plague-stricken Florence for a country villa and pass the time telling one another stories, a frame that has found new readers whenever epidemics return. In England, Isaac Newton spent much of 1665 and 1666 at his family home in Lincolnshire after the University of Cambridge closed because of plague, a period in which he developed some of his most important ideas. Not every supposed legacy survives scrutiny, however. The popular belief that the nursery rhyme 'Ring a Ring o' Roses' describes the plague is, folklorists point out, almost certainly a myth: the rhyme was first recorded centuries later, and the plague interpretation appeared later still.
Why, then, does the plague keep such a grip on the imagination? Part of the answer is scale: few events have reshaped so many lives so quickly. But part, Margaret Lowe suggests, is moral. 'People don't come here for the numbers,' she says as we walk back towards the church. 'They come because of a choice. Ordinary people decided that other people's safety mattered as much as their own. That's the bit that resonates.' Historians have debated how freely that choice was made, and how far later retellings have embellished it. Lowe is unbothered. 'Of course it's been polished. Stories always are. But the boundary stones are real.'
The shadow the plague casts is long, but it is not only dark. It falls across the language we speak, the institutions that protect us and the stories we tell about what neighbours owe one another. Eyam's stones, worn smooth by centuries of rain and curious fingers, are a reminder that the past is rarely as distant as it looks.