Every spring, the Bath Literary Society holds what it calls a symposium in the old sense of the word: a conversation over supper. (The Greek word originally meant a drinking party; this one ran on elderflower cordial.) This year the chair, Owen Lascelles, invited three guests to discuss happiness: Dr Imogen Searle, a classicist; Dr Calum Rennie, a psychologist who studies wellbeing; and Marguerite Olawale, a novelist. Their conversation has been shortened for publication.
Owen: Let's start with definitions, since I suspect that's where we'll disagree. Imogen? Imogen: The ancient Greeks had a word, eudaimonia, which we usually translate as happiness, though flourishing is closer. For Aristotle it wasn't a mood at all. It was the shape of a whole life lived well, an activity rather than a feeling. He has a famous line: one swallow does not make a summer. A single delightful afternoon doesn't make you happy in his sense, any more than one good lesson makes you a teacher. Calum: Which is lovely, but almost impossible to measure. When psychologists ask people how happy they are, we get something much more fleeting. And one of the most robust findings in my field is how quickly people get used to good news. A pay rise, a new house, a big win: within a year or so, most people drift back towards where they started. We call it adaptation. Owen: That sounds rather bleak. Calum: It's less bleak than it sounds. Adaptation works in both directions; it's also why people recover from setbacks better than they expect. And the things that resist adaptation are revealing: close friendships, absorbing work, a sense of being useful. Those don't wear off in the same way.
Marguerite: May I come in as the only person here without a footnote? When I write a novel, I notice that happiness is almost impossible to dramatise. Tolstoy put it unforgettably at the start of Anna Karenina: happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way. I'm not sure he was right about families, but he was right about fiction. Unhappiness gives you a plot. Happiness tends to arrive in the gaps between the chapters. Imogen: Which Aristotle would say proves his point: you can only judge a life as a whole. Marguerite: Perhaps. But I'd go further. I think we mostly recognise happiness in retrospect. Ask me whether I'm happy at this moment and I'll start to examine the feeling, and the examining spoils it. Ask me in ten years about this supper, and I may tell you I was very happy indeed. Happiness, for me, is something memory does to experience. Calum: There's research that partly supports that. How people remember an experience often depends heavily on its best moment and its ending, rather than on its total length. So the remembering self and the experiencing self don't always agree. Owen: Then which one should we trust? Calum: I'm wary of choosing. If we only trust memory, we may put up with years of misery for the sake of a good story afterwards. If we only trust the moment, we'd never do anything difficult, and difficult things are often what we're proudest of.
Owen: A practical question, then. Should we aim at happiness at all? Calum: Directly, probably not. There's a well-known paradox: the harder people chase happiness as a goal, the more they check themselves for it, and the more disappointed they tend to become. It seems to work best as a by-product of something else. Imogen: Aristotle would agree, though for different reasons. You don't aim at flourishing the way an archer aims at a target. You aim at doing things well: being a good friend, a careful craftsman, a fair neighbour. Flourishing is what that looks like from the outside, over time. Marguerite: And I'd add, as a novelist, that a little unhappiness is not the enemy. Some of the richest lives I know have plenty of sorrow in them. Contentment that can't survive a bad week isn't worth very much.
Owen: A last word from each of you. Imogen: Judge a life by its shape, not its moods. Calum: Invest in the things that don't wear off: people, absorbing work, being of use. Marguerite: And don't interrogate your happiness too closely while it's happening. It's shy. Owen: Then I won't ask any of you whether you've enjoyed this evening. I'll ask you in ten years.