Business books tend to celebrate success. Shelves are lined with the stories of founders who defied the odds, yet failure is far more common and arguably more instructive. A large proportion of new businesses close within their first few years, and even giants that once seemed unassailable can fade within a generation. Why does this happen, and is it always a bad thing?
The most obvious explanation is money. A business can be popular and still collapse if it runs out of cash. Many owners discover, too late, that profit on paper is not the same as money in the bank: if customers pay slowly while bills arrive promptly, even a growing firm can find itself unable to pay its staff. Accountants have a saying that 'turnover is vanity, profit is sanity, but cash flow is reality'. Rapid growth, paradoxically, can make the problem worse, because expansion usually has to be paid for before it pays off.
A second explanation concerns the market itself. Some firms fail not because they are badly run but because the world around them changes. The economist Joseph Schumpeter, writing in the first half of the twentieth century, described capitalism as a process of 'creative destruction', in which new products and methods constantly displace old ones. The makers of horse-drawn carriages were not necessarily incompetent; they were simply overtaken by the motor car. From this perspective, business failure is less a personal tragedy than an inevitable feature of a changing economy.
Yet it would be complacent to blame everything on circumstances. In the 1990s the Harvard professor Clayton Christensen put forward an idea he called 'the innovator's dilemma'. Successful companies, he argued, often fail precisely because they do what seems sensible: they listen closely to their best customers and improve the products those customers already like. Meanwhile, newcomers develop cheaper, simpler alternatives that look unimpressive at first and appeal only to a small or neglected group. By the time these alternatives have improved enough to attract mainstream buyers, the established firm has fallen behind. Seldom is the problem a lack of intelligence; more often it is the inertia that success itself creates.
Culture plays its part too. Researchers who study organisations have found that teams in which people feel unable to raise concerns tend to spot problems later. When bad news has to travel up through layers of management, it is often softened along the way, so that those at the top hear a reassuring version of events. Some of the most expensive business failures in history involved warnings that were made but not heeded.
It is worth remembering, however, that failure is not always the end of the story. Many successful entrepreneurs have one or more closed businesses behind them, and in some countries bankruptcy laws are designed to give honest owners a second chance rather than to punish them. Critics warn that making failure too easy could encourage reckless behaviour. Supporters reply that a society which stigmatises failure discourages precisely the kind of experimentation on which innovation depends.
What, then, separates the companies that last from those that do not? There is no single formula, but a few habits recur in the research: keeping a careful eye on cash, staying curious about customers who are not yet buying, and creating an atmosphere in which uncomfortable truths can be spoken aloud. None of these guarantees survival. Taken together, though, they tilt the odds in a company's favour.