Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 36 · Interview · 620 words

Automation and Craft

A furniture maker and a labour economist discuss whether traditional craft has a future in an age of machines and automation.

When Owen Pritchard set up his furniture workshop in a converted barn outside Ludlow, friends warned him that he was swimming against the tide. Machines, they pointed out, could produce a perfectly serviceable chair in minutes. Fifteen years on, his waiting list stretches to many months. Our features editor, Clara Haines, asked him and the labour economist Dr Ravi Sandhu whether craft has a future in an automated age.

Clara: Owen, people have been predicting the death of craft for two centuries. Why hasn't it happened? Owen: Partly because the prediction was always a little misguided. Factories didn't abolish handmade things; they changed what handmade things were for. Once a chair no longer had to be cheap, it was free to become something else: a piece of work you could trace back to a person. Ravi: That's a pattern economists recognise. When a product becomes mass-produced, its handmade version rarely disappears altogether. Instead it moves into a niche, often a smaller and more expensive one, where buyers are paying for qualities that a machine finds hard to reproduce.

Clara: The Luddites are usually remembered as people who simply hated machines. Is that fair? Ravi: Not really. The textile workers who broke machinery in the north of England in the early nineteenth century were protesting less against technology itself than against the way it was being used to cut wages and undermine skilled work. It's worth remembering, because the debate about automation today is, at heart, the same debate: not whether machines arrive, but who reaps the benefits when they do. Owen: And I'd add that craftspeople have never been against tools. I use a computer-controlled cutter for some of the repetitive work. It frees me to spend my time on the joints and the finish, which is where the real skill lies.

Clara: So is automation a threat to jobs or not? Ravi: The honest answer is that it depends on the task rather than the job. Research consistently suggests that machines are best at work that is routine and predictable. Few jobs consist entirely of such tasks, so what tends to happen is that jobs are reshaped rather than wiped out. That said, I wouldn't want to downplay the disruption. For a worker whose tasks have been automated, being told that the economy as a whole will adjust is cold comfort.

Clara: Owen, what do your customers actually want from you? Owen: Not perfection, interestingly. A factory can make every chair identical. People come to me because they want to know where the wood came from, who shaped it and why it looks the way it does. Some of them commission a piece to mark a wedding or a new home. What they're buying is partly an object and partly a story. Ravi: There's a risk there, though. If craft survives only as a luxury, it becomes something that affluent households enjoy while everyone else buys mass-produced goods. That isn't necessarily a problem, but it does mean that craft can't be the whole answer to automation.

Clara: What would you say to a young person thinking of learning a craft? Owen: Find someone to learn from. Hand skills are passed on through apprenticeships, by watching and making mistakes alongside someone experienced; you can't pick them up from a video alone. And learn the business side, because talent doesn't pay the rent on its own. Ravi: I'd say the same to almost anyone. The skills that are hardest to automate are those that combine judgement, dexterity and dealing with people. A good craftsperson has all three. Far from being a relic of the past, that combination may turn out to be one of the most future-proof things you can learn.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
swimming against the tide/ˌswɪmɪŋ əˌɡenst ðə ˈtaɪd/doing something different from what most people are doing
serviceable/ˈsɜːvɪsəbəl/good enough to be used, although not special
misguided/ˌmɪsˈɡaɪdɪd/based on wrong ideas or bad judgement
niche/niːʃ/a small, specialised part of a market
undermine/ˌʌndəˈmaɪn/to make something weaker, often slowly
reaps the benefits/ˌriːps ðə ˈbenɪfɪts/gets the good results or advantages of something
repetitive/rɪˈpetətɪv/done again and again in the same way, often boring
reshaped/ˌriːˈʃeɪpt/changed in form or organisation
downplay/ˌdaʊnˈpleɪ/to make something seem less important than it really is
cold comfort/ˌkəʊld ˈkʌmfət/something meant to make you feel better that does not really help
commission/kəˈmɪʃən/to ask someone to make a special piece of work for you and pay for it
affluent/ˈæfluənt/having a lot of money; rich
apprenticeships/əˈprentɪsʃɪps/periods of training in which you learn a skill by working with an expert
dexterity/dekˈsterəti/skill in using your hands
relic/ˈrelɪk/something left from an earlier time that is now old-fashioned
future-proof/ˈfjuːtʃə ˌpruːf/likely to stay useful even when things change in the future

Automation and Craft: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.