For much of the twentieth century, economists measured a nation's progress mainly through its output. If gross domestic product, the total value of the goods and services a country produces, was rising, things were assumed to be getting better. The assumption is not unreasonable: richer societies can afford better healthcare, education and housing. But a growing body of research asks a simpler and more awkward question. Are people actually any happier?
One of the first to pose it seriously was the American economist Richard Easterlin. In the 1970s he noticed something puzzling. Within any one country, richer people tended to report being happier than poorer ones. Yet over long periods, as whole countries grew richer, average happiness seemed to rise far less than income, and in some cases hardly at all. This apparent contradiction became known as the Easterlin paradox, and it has been debated ever since.
Several explanations have been offered. One is that people judge their circumstances relative to others: if my income rises but so does everyone else's, I may feel no better off. Another is adaptation: we quickly get used to improvements, so that a new car or a bigger flat delivers a burst of pleasure that soon fades. Psychologists sometimes call this the hedonic treadmill, since we keep running towards more without getting any further.
Not everyone accepts the paradox, however. Some economists argue that, with better data from more countries, a clearer link between income and life satisfaction does emerge, especially when poorer and richer nations are compared. Money, they point out, matters enormously to those who lack it: for a family struggling to pay for food or heating, extra income can transform daily life. The disagreement is partly about method, because happiness is usually measured simply by asking people to rate their lives on a scale, and critics question how reliable such self-reported answers can be.
What, apart from money, seems to matter? Here the research is surprisingly consistent. People with close relationships, good health and a sense of purpose tend to report higher wellbeing. Losing a job, by contrast, appears to hurt far more than the lost income alone would suggest, because work also provides structure, status and company. Long commutes are associated with lower satisfaction, while time spent with friends and family is associated with higher satisfaction. None of these findings is especially startling, yet they rarely feature in traditional economic statistics.
Such findings have begun to influence policy. Several governments now publish official measures of wellbeing alongside economic figures, and a few have experimented with budgets that explicitly aim to improve citizens' quality of life. Supporters argue that this encourages politicians to take mental health, community and the environment seriously. Sceptics worry that happiness is too subjective to guide public spending, and that governments should concentrate on providing the conditions for a good life rather than trying to measure people's feelings.
Perhaps the most useful lesson is a modest one. Economic growth is neither irrelevant to happiness nor a guarantee of it. Income is a means, not an end, and its value depends on what it allows people to do: to feel secure, to spend time with those they love, to pursue work they find meaningful. Measuring those things is difficult. Ignoring them, though, may be the costlier mistake.