A little over a century ago, two young cousins in the Yorkshire village of Cottingley produced photographs that appeared to show them playing with fairies. Among the people who believed the pictures were genuine was Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the creator of Sherlock Holmes – a writer famous for celebrating cool, logical reasoning. Decades later, the cousins admitted that the fairies had been paper cut-outs. The episode is often retold as an amusing curiosity, but it raises a serious question: how can a highly intelligent person be so thoroughly taken in?
Psychologists have increasingly come to recognise that intelligence and good judgement are not the same thing. Intelligence tests measure abilities such as reasoning, memory and the speed at which we process information. They are much less good at capturing what researchers call rationality: the tendency to weigh evidence fairly, to notice when we might be wrong and to change our minds when we should. Some people score highly on the first and surprisingly poorly on the second; one researcher even coined a term, "dysrationalia", to describe the gap.
Part of the problem is that intelligence can be put to work for the wrong purpose. All of us are prone to motivated reasoning – starting with the conclusion we want and then looking for arguments to support it. Clever people are not immune to this; if anything, they may be better at it. In one well-known study, people with strong numerical skills interpreted a table of figures accurately when the topic was neutral. Yet when the same figures touched on an issue they felt strongly about, many used their skills to explain away the inconvenient results. Greater intelligence, in other words, can simply mean more sophisticated excuses.
A second trap is overconfidence. Expertise in one field can create a sense of authority that people carry, often unwisely, into others. A brilliant engineer may assume that a talent for solving problems extends to medicine or economics, and so feel less need to check their views. Researchers have also described a bias blind spot: most of us are quick to see errors in other people's thinking and slow to see them in our own. Being intelligent does not appear to protect against this, and some studies suggest it may even make it slightly worse.
Dr Fiona MacLeod, who studies decision-making at a university in Edinburgh, puts it bluntly. "Intelligence is like the engine of a car," she says. "A more powerful engine will get you to your destination faster – but it will also take you a long way down the wrong road if you aren't checking the map." In her view, the crucial ingredient is not raw brainpower but a set of habits: pausing before committing to a view, actively looking for evidence against it and being willing to say, "I don't know."
This quality is often called intellectual humility, and it is attracting growing interest. Studies suggest that people who score higher on measures of it are better at telling strong arguments from weak ones and less likely to dismiss views they disagree with. Encouragingly, it seems to be at least partly a matter of practice. Simple techniques can help: deliberately "considering the opposite" before making a decision, imagining how a plan might fail, or asking a trusted friend to argue the other side.
None of this should be taken as an argument against intelligence, which remains a genuine asset in most areas of life. Nor does it mean that clever people are especially foolish; on many tasks, they make fewer errors than average. The point is narrower and more useful: being clever does not exempt anyone from the ordinary pitfalls of human thinking. If anything, those who are used to being right may need to guard against error more carefully, precisely because they rarely expect it.
It is worth remembering that Conan Doyle gave his most famous character a clear warning about this very danger. Holmes repeatedly cautions against forming theories before the facts are in. It is a rule that his creator, in his enthusiasm for the fairies, seems to have forgotten – and one that the rest of us would do well to remember.