Ask a room of keen readers why novels matter, and sooner or later someone will say that fiction makes us better people. By allowing us to live briefly inside another person's head, the argument runs, stories teach us to understand lives very different from our own. In the nineteenth century, the novelist George Eliot argued that the greatest benefit art gives us is the extension of our sympathies. It is an attractive idea, and one that many teachers, writers and parents instinctively accept. But is it true?
There are good reasons to think it might be. Reading a novel demands a particular kind of mental effort. We must keep track of what characters know, want and fear, often when they do not say so directly; we must notice when one character misunderstands another; and we must imagine reactions that the author merely hints at. Psychologists call the ability to understand other people's mental states theory of mind, and one researcher memorably described fiction as a kind of flight simulator for social life: a safe place to practise skills that we need in the real world.
Some evidence supports this picture. Surveys have repeatedly found that people who read a lot of fiction tend to score somewhat higher on tests of empathy and social understanding than those who mainly read non-fiction or read little at all. Brain-imaging studies suggest that reading about characters' thoughts activates regions also involved in thinking about real people. And a widely reported experiment once found that reading just a few pages of literary fiction briefly improved people's performance on a test in which they had to judge emotions from photographs of eyes.
Yet the picture becomes less clear the closer one looks. That striking experiment proved difficult to replicate: when other teams repeated it with larger groups, the effect largely disappeared. The survey findings, meanwhile, are correlational. They show that keen readers and empathetic people overlap, but not which causes which. It is entirely plausible that people who are already curious about others are drawn to novels, rather than novels making them curious. Separating these possibilities would require long-term studies that are difficult and expensive to carry out.
There is also the question of what kind of empathy we mean. Understanding what someone feels is not the same as caring about them, and caring is not the same as acting kindly. A reader may weep over a character's misfortune and then walk past a real person in need. Some critics go further, arguing that empathy is itself a double-edged quality: we tend to feel it most strongly for people who resemble us, and stories that encourage us to identify with one side can make us less fair to the other. Not every novel, after all, widens our sympathies; some narrow them.
None of this means that the original claim is false; rather, it is less straightforward than its enthusiasts suggest. A more cautious version might run as follows. Fiction offers opportunities to imagine other lives, and some readers, some of the time, take those opportunities in ways that make them more understanding. The effect probably depends on what is read, how it is read and what happens afterwards. Discussing a book with others may matter as much as reading it alone, because it forces us to confront interpretations that differ from our own.
Laura Bennett, who runs a reading group at a secondary school in Norwich, describes something similar. "When we started a novel about a refugee family, some pupils saw the characters as distant figures," she says. "A few weeks later, they were arguing about why the mother made a particular decision, and defending points of view they would once have dismissed." Whether such changes last is hard to measure, but it would be difficult to call them nothing.
Perhaps the safest conclusion is that fiction is neither a vaccine against prejudice nor a guaranteed course in kindness. It is better thought of as an invitation. Novels cannot make us empathetic, but they can give us practice, and practice, as anyone who has learnt a musical instrument knows, is not to be underestimated.