Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 18 · Debate · 601 words

Nudge Theory

A behavioural scientist and a philosopher debate whether gentle 'nudges' are a smart way to help people or a quiet form of manipulation.

In 2008, two American academics, an economist and a legal scholar, published a book called Nudge. It argued that small changes in the way choices are presented can steer people towards better decisions without forbidding anything. The idea proved remarkably influential: in 2010 the UK government set up a Behavioural Insights Team, soon nicknamed the "Nudge Unit", and many other countries followed. But is nudging a clever way to help people, or a gentle form of manipulation? At a public event in Bristol, we asked Dr Priya Lambert, a behavioural scientist, and Tom Ashworth, a philosopher, to debate the question.

Chair: Priya, let's begin with a definition. Lambert: A nudge is any feature of the way a choice is presented – what we call the choice architecture – that changes behaviour in a predictable way without removing options or significantly changing financial incentives. Putting fruit at eye level in a school canteen is a nudge. Banning crisps is not. Chair: And why should governments bother? Lambert: Because we're not the perfectly rational calculators that traditional economics assumed. We procrastinate, we stick with whatever is already set up, and we're easily swayed by what other people do. One of the most powerful tools is the default. When workplace pensions in the UK moved to automatic enrolment, so that employees were included unless they chose to opt out, the proportion of people saving rose dramatically. Nobody was forced; the starting point simply changed.

Chair: Tom, that sounds hard to object to. Ashworth: I don't object to every nudge. Reminder letters and clearer forms are perfectly sensible. My concern is with the underlying philosophy. Its supporters call it "libertarian paternalism": you remain free, but someone else has decided what's good for you and arranged the world accordingly. Who decides? And many nudges work precisely because people don't notice them. If a technique only succeeds when it goes unnoticed, I'm entitled to ask whether it treats people as adults. Lambert: But there's no neutral option. A canteen has to put the food somewhere; a form has to have a default box. Choice architecture is unavoidable, so the question isn't whether to influence people but how. I'd rather it was designed openly and in people's interests than left to chance – or to companies, who are nudging us all the time to spend more. Ashworth: That's a fair point, and businesses are certainly the bigger worry. But governments hold special power, so the standard should be higher. I'd insist on transparency: if a nudge couldn't be publicly defended, it shouldn't be used. Lambert: On that we agree. The book's authors said much the same.

Chair: What about the evidence? Do nudges actually work? Lambert: Some work extremely well – defaults especially. Others turn out to be weaker than early studies suggested. Ashworth: That's something of an understatement, if I may say so. Later reviews have found that the average effect of many nudges is smaller once you account for publication bias – the tendency for striking results to be published while disappointing ones stay in a drawer. And there's a risk of complacency: a government might send a cheerful letter about healthy eating instead of tackling the deeper reasons why some families can't afford good food. Lambert: Nudges were never meant to replace other policies, only to complement them. Used alongside regulation, education and taxes, they're cheap and often effective.

Chair: A final word from each of you? Ashworth: Nudge if you must, but nudge in daylight. Lambert: And remember that we're always being nudged by someone. Better that it's done thoughtfully, and in the open.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
steer/stɪə/to guide someone or something in a particular direction
manipulation/məˌnɪpjəˈleɪʃən/influencing people in a hidden or unfair way
choice architecture/ˈtʃɔɪs ˌɑːkɪtektʃə/the way choices are arranged and shown to people
incentives/ɪnˈsentɪvz/things such as money or rewards that make people want to do something
rational/ˈræʃənəl/based on clear, logical thinking
procrastinate/prəˈkræstɪneɪt/to keep delaying something that you should do
swayed/sweɪd/influenced to think or act in a certain way
default/dɪˈfɔːlt/what happens or is chosen automatically if you do nothing
opt out/ˌɒpt ˈaʊt/to choose not to take part in something
libertarian paternalism/ˌlɪbəˌteəriən pəˈtɜːnəlɪzəm/the idea of guiding people towards good choices while leaving them free to choose
transparency/trænˈspærənsi/being open and honest so that people can see what is happening
understatement/ˌʌndəˈsteɪtmənt/saying something is less serious or smaller than it really is
publication bias/ˌpʌblɪˈkeɪʃən ˌbaɪəs/when exciting research results are published more often than disappointing ones
complacency/kəmˈpleɪsənsi/being too satisfied, so you stop trying hard enough
complement/ˈkɒmplɪment/to add to something in a way that makes it better or more complete

Nudge Theory: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.