Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 17 · Interview · 637 words

Memory Is Not a Recording

A cognitive psychologist explains why our memories are rebuilt rather than replayed, and what that means for witnesses, families and all of us.

Most of us assume that memory works rather like a video camera: events are recorded, stored and later played back. In this interview, Dr Imogen Hartley, a cognitive psychologist who studies memory at a university in York, explains why that comparison is deeply misleading.

Interviewer: Let's start with the obvious question. If memory isn't a recording, what is it? Dr Hartley: The best word is probably reconstruction. When you remember something, you don't press "play" on a stored file. Your brain rebuilds the event from fragments – a few details, a feeling, what you know usually happens in situations like that – and fills in the gaps. Most of the time the result is good enough, which is why we rarely notice the process. Interviewer: Is this a new idea? Dr Hartley: Not at all. In the early twentieth century, the Cambridge psychologist Frederic Bartlett asked people to read an unfamiliar folk tale from another culture and retell it after different periods of time. With each retelling, the story drifted further from the original. Strange details disappeared or were replaced by things that made more sense to the readers. Bartlett concluded that we remember through schemas – mental frameworks of what we expect – rather than by storing exact copies.

Interviewer: How easily can memories be changed? Dr Hartley: More easily than most people find comfortable. In some famous experiments in the 1970s, volunteers watched a film of a car accident and were then asked how fast the cars were going when they "hit" each other, or when they "smashed" into each other. The "smashed" group gave higher estimates of speed and, a week later, were more likely to say they had seen broken glass, although there had been none. A single word in a question had subtly reshaped the memory. Later research went further: after repeated suggestion, some people came to remember whole childhood events that had never happened, such as being lost in a shopping centre. Interviewer: That sounds rather alarming. Dr Hartley: It can be, especially in a courtroom. Eyewitness testimony is extremely persuasive to juries, yet studies of wrongful convictions have shown that mistaken identification played a part in many of them. That's why many police forces now follow careful procedures: asking open questions, avoiding hints and recording how confident a witness is at the very first identification, before that confidence has a chance to grow.

Interviewer: Surely some memories are reliable, though – the really vivid ones? Dr Hartley: You'd think so. People often describe so-called flashbulb memories of where they were when they heard shocking news, and they feel absolutely certain about them. But when researchers have questioned people soon after such events and again years later, the stories have often changed considerably, while the confidence stayed high. Vividness and accuracy, it turns out, are not the same thing. Interviewer: Why would the brain work in such an unreliable way? Dr Hartley: I'd question the word "unreliable". A flexible memory has real advantages. Remembering the gist of things rather than every detail allows us to generalise, to learn from experience and to imagine the future, which uses many of the same brain processes as remembering the past. There's also evidence that each time we recall a memory, it briefly becomes open to updating before it is stored again. That's a weakness if you're a witness, but a strength if you're learning.

Interviewer: So what should ordinary people take from all this? Dr Hartley: A little humility. If you and your brother remember a family holiday differently, it's quite possible that neither of you is lying – and that neither of you is entirely right. Writing things down soon after they happen certainly helps. And when we feel sure about a memory, it's worth remembering that certainty is a feeling, not proof.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
misleading/ˌmɪsˈliːdɪŋ/giving a wrong idea or impression
reconstruction/ˌriːkənˈstrʌkʃən/building something again from its parts
fragments/ˈfræɡmənts/small pieces of something larger
folk tale/ˈfəʊk ˌteɪl/a traditional story that people have told for a very long time
schemas/ˈskiːməz/ideas in the mind about how things usually are or happen
subtly/ˈsʌtli/in a small way that is difficult to notice
eyewitness testimony/ˈaɪwɪtnəs ˌtestɪməni/what a person who saw an event says about it, especially in court
persuasive/pəˈsweɪsɪv/able to make people believe something
wrongful convictions/ˌrɒŋfəl kənˈvɪkʃənz/cases where a court decides that an innocent person is guilty
flashbulb memories/ˈflæʃbʌlb ˌmeməriz/very clear memories of the moment when you heard surprising or shocking news
vividness/ˈvɪvɪdnəs/how clear, bright and detailed something seems
gist/dʒɪst/the main idea or general meaning of something
generalise/ˈdʒenərəlaɪz/to form a general idea from a number of examples
humility/hjuːˈmɪləti/the quality of not thinking you are always right or better than others

Memory Is Not a Recording: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.