Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 16 · Feature · 695 words

Creativity and Boredom

A feature that asks whether a little boredom can help us think more creatively, and where the idea reaches its limits.

On a grey Tuesday afternoon in a primary school in Kendal, a class of nine-year-olds is doing something that might alarm many parents: absolutely nothing. For fifteen minutes there are no screens, no worksheets and no instructions, only a box of odds and ends on each table. Their teacher, Rachel Penrose, calls it "empty time". "At first they complained that it was boring," she says. "Now they invent games, write plays and build things I would never have thought of. Hardly anyone asks me what to do any more."

Penrose is not alone in suspecting that boredom has been given an unfairly bad name. For most of us it is a feeling to be eliminated as quickly as possible, and modern life makes that remarkably easy: a phone in a pocket means that no queue, bus journey or waiting room need ever be dull again. Yet a growing number of psychologists argue that this constant stimulation may come at a cost, and that a little boredom, far from being wasted time, can be the soil in which new ideas grow.

The evidence, though still developing, is intriguing. In one widely discussed study, British researchers asked some volunteers to carry out a deliberately tedious task, such as copying out long lists of numbers, before giving them a classic creativity test: thinking of as many uses as possible for an everyday object like a plastic cup. Those who had been bored first tended to come up with more ideas, and more unusual ones, than those who had not. Similar experiments have produced broadly comparable results, although the effects are usually modest.

Why should this be? One explanation centres on mind-wandering. When the world around us offers little to hold our attention, our thoughts drift inwards: we replay conversations, imagine the future and make loose connections between ideas that do not normally meet. Brain-imaging research has identified a network of regions that becomes more active precisely when we are not focused on an outside task, and some scientists believe this network plays a part in incubation, the process by which a problem we have stopped consciously thinking about is quietly worked on in the background. It is no coincidence, perhaps, that so many people claim their best ideas arrive in the shower or on a long walk.

A second explanation sees boredom as a signal rather than a state. Just as hunger tells us to eat, boredom tells us that what we are doing lacks meaning or challenge, and prompts us to look for something better. Seen this way, the feeling is less an enemy of creativity than a push towards it – provided that we respond by exploring rather than by reaching straight for the nearest distraction.

Not everyone is convinced. Dr Samuel Okoro, a developmental psychologist, warns against romanticising boredom. "There is a difference between a short, empty afternoon and chronic boredom," he points out. "Children who are persistently under-stimulated, at home or at school, do not usually become more inventive. They become disengaged, and in some cases unhappy." He also notes that boredom affects people differently: what feels like a creative pause to one person can feel like quiet frustration to another.

There is, moreover, the matter of what we do with the empty moment. In a series of studies in which people were left alone in a room with nothing but their own thoughts, many found the experience surprisingly unpleasant, even after only a few minutes. Boredom, in other words, does not automatically produce creativity; it creates an opportunity that we may or may not take.

So what is the practical lesson? Most researchers stop well short of recommending that we deliberately make ourselves miserable. Rather, they suggest that we stop treating every spare minute as a gap to be filled. Leaving the phone in a bag on the train, allowing children some unstructured time at the weekend or simply taking a walk without headphones may give the mind the room it needs to wander. As Penrose puts it: "I don't give them boredom as a punishment. I give it to them as a space. What they put in it is up to them."

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
odds and ends/ˌɒdz ənd ˈendz/small objects of different kinds that are not worth much
eliminated/ɪˈlɪmɪneɪtɪd/removed completely
stimulation/ˌstɪmjəˈleɪʃən/things that keep your mind busy and interested
soil/sɔɪl/the earth that plants grow in; here, the place where something starts and develops
intriguing/ɪnˈtriːɡɪŋ/very interesting because it is unusual or not fully understood
tedious/ˈtiːdiəs/long, dull and boring
modest/ˈmɒdɪst/not very large
mind-wandering/ˈmaɪnd ˌwɒndərɪŋ/when your thoughts move freely from one thing to another without a plan
drift/drɪft/to move slowly without a clear direction
incubation/ˌɪŋkjuˈbeɪʃn/a period when an idea develops slowly in your mind without you trying
prompts/prɒmpts/makes someone decide to do something
romanticising/rəʊˈmæntɪsaɪzɪŋ/making something seem better or more attractive than it really is
chronic/ˈkrɒnɪk/lasting for a long time or happening again and again
disengaged/ˌdɪsɪnˈɡeɪdʒd/no longer interested or involved
unstructured/ʌnˈstrʌktʃəd/without a fixed plan or organised activities

Creativity and Boredom: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.