Walk into a large supermarket and you may find dozens of varieties of breakfast cereal, an entire aisle of shampoo and more kinds of bread than you could try in a month. Common sense tells us that this is a good thing. More options mean a better chance of finding exactly what we want, and the freedom to choose is widely regarded as a mark of a healthy society. Yet in the early 2000s, the American psychologist Barry Schwartz popularised a provocative counter-argument: beyond a certain point, more choice may actually make us less happy. He called this the paradox of choice.
Schwartz drew on a now-famous experiment carried out by the psychologists Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper in an upmarket food shop in California. On some days, shoppers passing a tasting stand were offered a selection of 24 jams; on others, just six. The larger display attracted more attention, with more people stopping to taste. But when it came to buying, the pattern was reversed: shoppers who had seen the smaller selection were considerably more likely to go on to purchase a jar. Faced with too many alternatives, it seemed, many people simply walked away.
Schwartz offered several explanations. Comparing a large number of options demands time and mental effort, and the effort itself can be draining. Abundant choice also raises our expectations: if there are fifty pairs of jeans to choose from, surely one of them must be perfect, so anything less feels like a failure. And having chosen, we are more vulnerable to regret, because it is easy to imagine that one of the rejected options would have been better. With only two possibilities, a disappointing purchase can be blamed on the world. With fifty, it feels like our own fault.
Schwartz also argued that people differ in how they handle choice. Borrowing a term coined by the economist Herbert Simon, he contrasted 'satisficers', who search until they find something that meets their standards and then stop, with 'maximisers', who feel compelled to find the very best option available. Research suggests that maximisers sometimes achieve objectively better outcomes – a slightly higher salary, for example – yet tend to feel less satisfied with them, perhaps because they keep wondering what they might have missed.
Compelling as the argument is, the evidence has turned out to be more complicated than the jam study implies. When researchers tried to repeat such experiments, the results were mixed: in some studies, large assortments put people off; in others, they made no difference or even increased satisfaction. Reviews combining many studies concluded that the average effect of 'choice overload' is close to zero – although this average conceals real effects under particular conditions.
So when does too much choice become a burden? The answer seems to depend on circumstances. Overload is more likely when the options are difficult to compare, when people have no clear idea of what they want, when they are under time pressure, or when the decision feels important. Someone who knows exactly which flavour they like will hardly be troubled by a shelf of fifty; a first-time buyer facing a bewildering range of complicated mobile phone contracts may well be.
What, then, can we take from the debate? Perhaps the most useful lesson is not that choice is bad, but that it has costs as well as benefits. For decisions that matter little, adopting the satisficer's approach – deciding what is 'good enough' and then stopping – can save a great deal of time and anxiety. Shops and websites, for their part, can help by grouping options sensibly or offering clear recommendations. Freedom of choice remains valuable. It is simply that, like many good things, it is best enjoyed in moderation.