Few ideas from psychology have travelled as far into schools as 'growth mindset'. On this edition of the education programme Classroom Questions, presenter Lucy Shaw asks two guests whether the idea deserves its reputation: Daniel Price, a secondary school head teacher in Norwich, and Dr Sarah Lindqvist, an educational researcher.
Lucy: Daniel, for anyone who hasn't come across the term, what is a growth mindset? Daniel: The idea comes from the work of the American psychologist Carol Dweck. She suggested that people hold different beliefs about ability. Some see intelligence as fixed – you either have it or you don't. Others see it as something that can grow through effort, good strategies and help from others. Her research suggested that students with the second belief, a growth mindset, are more likely to persist when work gets difficult, because they see mistakes as part of learning rather than proof that they're not clever enough. Lucy: Sarah, it sounds very appealing. Why are you sceptical? Sarah: I should say first that I'm not against the idea itself. My concern is with the way it's been marketed. For a while it was presented almost as a cure-all: change a child's mindset and their grades will soar. When independent researchers tested mindset programmes on a large scale, the average effects turned out to be modest at best, and some studies found no measurable benefit at all.
Lucy: Daniel, does that worry you? Daniel: Not greatly, to be honest. Even a modest effect matters if it's achieved cheaply, and some of the larger studies found the clearest gains among students who were struggling. That's exactly the group we most want to help. And in my experience, the language we use does shape the classroom climate. When teachers praise only intelligence – 'You're so clever!' – some children become afraid of tasks that might expose them. Sarah: That's a fair point, and there is research behind it. In well-known experiments, children praised for being clever were more likely afterwards to choose easier tasks than children praised for their effort. But the problem is what happens when an idea is watered down. Dweck herself has warned about what she calls a 'false growth mindset' – praising effort even when it isn't working, or telling a child to 'just try harder' without showing them how.
Lucy: So it can go wrong in practice? Sarah: Very easily. A poster in the corridor saying 'Mistakes help you grow' is not an intervention. If a pupil keeps making the same mistake, what they need is a better strategy and good feedback, not a slogan. There's also a risk of putting the blame on children: if you fail, it must be because your mindset is wrong, rather than because the teaching or your circumstances let you down. Daniel: I'd agree with that entirely. In our school, we've stopped talking about mindset as a separate thing. Instead, we try to build it into everyday teaching: giving pupils challenging work, showing them how to improve, and making it normal to ask for help.
Lucy: Let me ask you both for a verdict. Hype or help? Sarah: A bit of both, I'm afraid. The core insight is sound, but the claims made on its behalf were inflated. It's not a magic bullet. Daniel: I'd call it a helpful idea that needs to be done properly. On its own, it won't transform a school. Combined with good teaching, it can make a real difference to how pupils see themselves. Lucy: A neat point of agreement to end on. Thank you both.