Imagine receiving a fixed sum of money from the government every month, whether you are rich or poor, employed or not, with no forms to fill in and no questions asked. This, in essence, is universal basic income (UBI). Once dismissed as a utopian fantasy, the idea has moved from the fringes of political debate towards the mainstream, attracting supporters – and critics – from across the political spectrum.
The concept is far from new. In the sixteenth century, Thomas More's book Utopia suggested that it would be wiser to provide everyone with a means of making a livelihood than to punish people who stole out of hunger. In the late eighteenth century, the radical thinker Thomas Paine proposed that every citizen should receive a lump sum on reaching adulthood. What has revived interest today is a combination of pressures: fears that automation will erode traditional jobs, frustration with complicated welfare systems, and the growing number of people in insecure, irregular work.
Advocates argue that UBI would offer a safety net without the stigma that is sometimes attached to claiming benefits. Because everyone receives it, nobody has to prove that they are poor enough, ill enough or searching hard enough for work. Supporters also point to the so-called poverty trap: under many existing systems, people who take a low-paid job may lose so much in benefits that they are scarcely better off. A universal payment, which is never withdrawn, would remove that disincentive. 'The beauty of it is its simplicity,' says Dr Helen Marsh, an economist at a university in Leeds. 'It treats people as adults who know their own needs best.'
Critics, however, raise serious objections. The most obvious is cost. A payment generous enough to live on, given to every adult, would require either substantial tax rises or deep cuts to other public services – or both. A smaller payment, on the other hand, might be affordable but would hardly transform anyone's life. Others question the principle itself. Why, they ask, should a millionaire receive the same sum as a struggling single parent? Targeted support, they argue, directs limited resources to those who need them most. There is also the fear that some people might choose to work less, although this is hotly contested.
So what does the evidence say? Here, caution is needed. Several countries and cities have run pilot schemes, the best known being a two-year experiment in Finland, in which a group of unemployed people received a monthly payment that continued even if they found work. Participants reported lower stress and greater confidence in the future, while the effect on employment was modest. Similar studies elsewhere have produced broadly encouraging results on wellbeing. Yet sceptics point out that a temporary trial involving a limited group can tell us little about what would happen if an entire nation received the money permanently and paid for it through taxes.
Between these two camps lie a number of compromise proposals. Some economists favour a 'negative income tax', under which people earning below a certain level receive money from the state rather than paying it. Others suggest a more modest payment for particular groups, such as carers, whose unpaid work currently goes largely unrewarded.
Ultimately, the debate over UBI is not only about economics but also about values. It raises fundamental questions about what we owe one another, and about the place of paid work in a good life. Whether or not it is ever introduced on a national scale, the idea has prompted a valuable rethink of how societies support their citizens. As Dr Marsh puts it, 'Even if UBI turns out not to be the answer, it has forced us to ask better questions.'