Artificial intelligence is changing how we work, learn and communicate, but it also raises difficult moral questions. We spoke to Professor Nadia Kerr, a philosopher at a university in Edinburgh who has spent more than a decade studying the ethics of technology, about where the real dangers lie – and why she remains cautiously optimistic.
Interviewer: Many people's fears about AI come from science fiction – machines turning against their creators. Are those fears misplaced? Professor Kerr: Not entirely, but they can be a distraction. Some researchers take long-term risks seriously, and I think they are right to. However, if we focus only on dramatic future scenarios, we may overlook the problems that are already here. Those are less cinematic, but they affect real people today.
Interviewer: Such as? Professor Kerr: Bias is the obvious example. AI systems learn from data, and data reflects the world as it has been, including its unfairness. If a recruitment tool is trained on the CVs of people a company has hired in the past, it may learn to favour candidates who resemble them. No one programmed it to discriminate, yet the outcome can be unfair all the same. What makes this especially troubling is that a computer's decision often appears objective, so people are less inclined to question it.
Interviewer: Can't engineers simply remove the bias? Professor Kerr: They can reduce it, and many are working hard to do so. But it is rarely simple. Fairness itself can be defined in several ways, and these definitions sometimes conflict. Deciding which one to apply is not a technical question; it is a moral and political one. That is precisely why philosophers, lawyers and the public need to be involved, not just programmers.
Interviewer: Another concern people raise is the so-called 'black box' problem. Professor Kerr: Yes. Some of the most powerful systems reach conclusions in ways that even their designers struggle to explain. If an AI helps decide whether someone gets a loan or medical treatment, that person surely deserves to know why. Transparency matters, and so does accountability. When something goes wrong, who is responsible – the company that built the system, the organisation that used it, or the person who followed its advice? At present, the answers are often unclear.
Interviewer: Should governments step in with strict rules? Professor Kerr: Some regulation is clearly needed, and several governments have begun to introduce it. But there is a balance to strike. Rules that are too vague achieve little, while rules that are too rigid could stifle useful innovation or quickly become outdated. Not only does the technology change rapidly, but it is also used in very different settings. A chatbot recommending films and a system that helps diagnose illness do not carry the same risks, so it makes sense to regulate them differently.
Interviewer: You describe yourself as optimistic. Why? Professor Kerr: Because AI can do enormous good. It is already helping scientists understand diseases, assisting people with disabilities and making information more accessible. The ethical questions are not reasons to abandon the technology; they are reasons to shape it carefully. Ultimately, AI will reflect the values of those who design it and the societies that use it. The question is not whether machines can be moral, but whether we will insist on responsible choices.
Interviewer: And what can ordinary people do? Professor Kerr: Stay curious and stay sceptical. Ask where information comes from, notice when a decision about you has been automated, and remember that 'the computer says so' is never a complete explanation.