Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 49 · Essay · 685 words

The Power of Metaphor

An essay arguing that metaphor is not just decoration for poets but a basic tool of thought that can shape how we see problems.

We tend to think of metaphor as something that belongs to poets. When Shakespeare's Romeo declares that Juliet is the sun, we recognise a figure of speech, a deliberate flourish designed to delight the ear and stir the imagination. Aristotle, writing more than two thousand years ago, regarded a command of metaphor as a sign of genius, something that could not be learnt from others. For centuries afterwards, metaphor was largely treated as ornament: attractive, perhaps, but separate from the plain business of saying what we mean.

That view began to change in the late twentieth century. In their influential book 'Metaphors We Live By', the linguist George Lakoff and the philosopher Mark Johnson argued that metaphor is not a decoration laid on top of ordinary language but woven into the way we think. Consider how we talk about arguments. We defend our claims, attack weak points, demolish an opponent's case and, with luck, win. Lakoff and Johnson's point was that we do not merely describe arguments in terms of battle; to some extent, we experience them that way, as contests with winners and losers. Similarly, we spend, save, waste and run out of time, as if it were money. We feel up or down; our spirits rise and sink. Such patterns are so pervasive that we rarely notice them at all.

Many of these are what linguists call dead metaphors: expressions whose original image has faded. Nobody pictures a human limb when they mention the leg of a table, or imagines a hand closing around an object when they say they have grasped an idea. Yet the underlying images have not entirely lost their force. Because we understand abstract things such as time, ideas and emotions through more concrete experiences, metaphor may be less a stylistic choice than a basic tool of thought.

If that is so, the metaphors we choose may shape the conclusions we reach. In one widely discussed experiment, two groups of volunteers read almost identical reports about rising crime in an imaginary city. For one group, crime was described as a beast preying on the city; for the other, it was a virus infecting it. Asked what should be done, readers of the first version were more likely to favour catching and punishing criminals, while readers of the second leaned towards tackling causes such as poverty. Few participants mentioned the metaphor when explaining their choices; they believed they had simply responded to the facts. It should be said that later studies have found the effect to be smaller and less consistent than this first result suggested. Even so, the experiment illustrates how a single word can frame a problem.

Science, too, depends on metaphor, for better and for worse. Describing DNA as a code or the brain as a computer has helped generations of students make sense of complex systems and has inspired productive research. But every metaphor highlights some features while hiding others. A computer is designed, programmed and can be switched off and restarted; a brain grows, changes with experience and is bound up with the body in ways no machine is. Scientists who take a metaphor too literally risk asking the wrong questions. The wiser approach is to use a metaphor as a ladder, not a cage.

None of this means we should try to purge metaphor from our language; that would be impossible even if it were desirable. A well-chosen metaphor can illuminate an idea in a way that pages of literal explanation cannot, which is why good teachers and writers wield them so skilfully. What it does suggest is that metaphors deserve scrutiny. When a politician calls a policy a 'battle', a company describes its staff as a 'family' or a news report speaks of a 'tidal wave' of complaints, it is worth pausing to ask what the image invites us to feel – and what it quietly leaves out. Metaphor is not merely the poet's tool. It is one of the lenses through which all of us see the world, and the first step towards seeing clearly is noticing that the lens is there.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
flourish/ˈflʌrɪʃ/a decorative extra in speech or writing, added for effect
ornament/ˈɔːnəmənt/decoration that makes something look nicer but is not necessary
woven into/ˌwəʊvən ˈɪntuː/closely mixed into something so that it is a basic part of it
demolish/dɪˈmɒlɪʃ/completely destroy; here, prove an argument totally wrong
pervasive/pəˈveɪsɪv/found everywhere
dead metaphors/ˌded ˈmetəfəz/expressions that were once images but are now used without thinking of the picture
grasped/ɡrɑːspt/understood
abstract/ˈæbstrækt/existing as an idea or feeling, not as a physical object
preying on/ˈpreɪɪŋ ɒn/hunting and harming weaker victims
frame/freɪm/present something in a particular way that affects how people see it
bound up with/ˌbaʊnd ˈʌp wɪð/very closely connected to
purge/pɜːdʒ/remove something completely
illuminate/ɪˈluːmɪneɪt/make something clearer and easier to understand
wield/wiːld/use something with skill and power
scrutiny/ˈskruːtɪni/careful and critical examination
lenses/ˈlenzɪz/curved pieces of glass that change how things look; here, ways of seeing

The Power of Metaphor: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.