Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 31 · Article · 659 words

The Attention Economy

An article about the attention economy: why many free online services compete for our time, how this shapes their design, and how people are responding.

In 1971, the economist and psychologist Herbert Simon made an observation that seems more relevant with every passing year. A wealth of information, he argued, creates a poverty of attention. When information is scarce, the challenge is finding it; when it is abundant, the challenge becomes deciding what to ignore. Half a century later, Simon's remark has become the starting point for discussions of what is now widely called the attention economy.

The basic idea is simple. Many of the digital services we use every day, from search engines and social media platforms to video sites and free games, cost nothing to use. Yet they are run by companies that employ large numbers of people and must, somehow, make money. For a great many of them, the answer is advertising. Advertisers pay to reach an audience, and the larger and more engaged that audience is, the more valuable it becomes. In this model, it is our time and attention, rather than our money, that is being traded. Hence the often-quoted remark that if you are not paying for the product, you may well be the product.

This has consequences for how such services are designed. If income depends on how long people stay, then designers have a strong incentive to keep them there. Critics point to features such as infinite scroll, which removes the natural stopping point at the bottom of a page; autoplay, which starts the next video before you have decided whether you want it; and notifications, which tug us back with a small red dot. Some of these features draw on well-established findings in psychology. Rewards that arrive unpredictably, such as a new message, a like or an interesting post, are known to be particularly effective at encouraging people to keep checking.

Not everyone accepts the gloomier version of this story, however. Defenders of the industry point out that advertising has funded free newspapers, radio and television for generations, and that the arrangement has given billions of people access to information, entertainment and ways of communicating they could never otherwise have afforded. They also argue that engagement is not inherently sinister: people spend time on things they find useful or enjoyable, and a service that nobody valued would soon be abandoned. Some researchers, too, caution against sweeping claims about 'addiction', noting that the evidence on the effects of screen time is mixed and that much depends on what people are actually doing online.

What is harder to dispute is that attention is a finite resource. There are only so many hours in a day, and every minute spent on one thing is a minute not spent on another. Economists call this opportunity cost, and it applies as much to an evening spent scrolling as to money spent in a shop. Seen this way, the competition for our attention is not only between rival apps but between screens and everything else: conversation, sleep, sport, reading and simply doing nothing at all.

Responses to the problem vary. Some governments and regulators have begun to look more closely at design practices, particularly where children are concerned. Some technology companies have introduced tools that let users set time limits or see how long they have spent on an app. Meanwhile, a growing number of individuals are experimenting with what is sometimes called digital minimalism: switching off non-essential notifications, keeping phones out of bedrooms, or deliberately choosing services that charge a subscription rather than relying on advertising.

Perhaps the most useful lesson of the attention economy, though, is a personal one. Attention, as Simon recognised, is something we spend, whether or not we notice ourselves doing so. Rarely do we think of an hour online as a purchase, yet in a sense that is exactly what it is. Becoming a more deliberate consumer of our own attention, and asking now and then whether something is really worth our time, may be one of the more valuable skills of the digital age.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
poverty of attention/ˌpɒvəti əv əˈtenʃən/a situation in which people do not have enough attention to give to everything
abundant/əˈbʌndənt/existing in very large amounts; more than enough
incentive/ɪnˈsentɪv/a reason that encourages someone to do something
infinite scroll/ˌɪnfɪnət ˈskrəʊl/a web page that keeps loading new content as you move down, so it never ends
tug us back/ˌtʌɡ əs ˈbæk/gently pull our attention back again
unpredictably/ˌʌnprɪˈdɪktəbli/at times that nobody can know in advance
engagement/ɪnˈɡeɪdʒmənt/how much people use something and take part in it
inherently/ɪnˈhɪərəntli/as a basic part of its nature; in itself
sinister/ˈsɪnɪstə/seeming harmful, dangerous or evil
sweeping claims/ˌswiːpɪŋ ˈkleɪmz/statements that are too general and go further than the facts allow
finite/ˈfaɪnaɪt/limited; there is only a certain amount of it
opportunity cost/ˌɒpəˈtjuːnəti ˌkɒst/what you lose when you choose one thing instead of another
regulators/ˈreɡjəleɪtəz/official bodies that make sure companies follow rules
digital minimalism/ˌdɪdʒɪtəl ˈmɪnɪməlɪzəm/a way of life in which you use technology less and only in ways you have chosen
deliberate/dɪˈlɪbərət/careful and done on purpose, after thinking

The Attention Economy: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.