For perhaps the first time in history, many workplaces now bring together four generations: people in their sixties who are delaying retirement, colleagues in mid-career, and young employees who have never known a world without the internet. Popular articles are full of sweeping claims about each group: that older workers resist technology, that younger ones expect promotion within months. To find out how much of this holds up, our reporter Liam Fletcher visited an engineering firm in Derby and spoke to Dr Helen Carr, an occupational psychologist.
Liam: Dr Carr, are generational differences at work real? Helen: Some are, but they're much smaller than the headlines suggest. When researchers compare large groups of workers carefully, most of the things people want from a job, such as fair pay, interesting work, respect and a decent manager, turn out to be remarkably similar across age groups. Many of the differences that do exist relate to life stage rather than generation. A twenty-five-year-old and a fifty-five-year-old want different things, but so did twenty-five- and fifty-five-year-olds forty years ago. Liam: So the labels are misleading? Helen: They can be useful shorthand, but they become harmful when they turn into stereotypes. If a manager assumes that an older employee won't want to learn new software, she may never be offered the training, and the assumption becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
At the Derby firm, the team that designs components for trains includes four colleagues born decades apart. Margaret, the most senior engineer, joined the company straight from school. 'When I started, you learnt by watching the person next to you,' she says. 'I've seen three or four completely different ways of drawing a design. You adapt or you get left behind, and I've always rather enjoyed adapting.' Her colleague Paul describes himself as the team's translator. 'I remember both the paper drawings and the first computers, so I often end up explaining each side to the other.'
The two youngest members are Aisha, who joined as a graduate engineer about ten years ago, and Ben, who came through the firm's apprenticeship scheme. Aisha values flexibility. 'I'm happy to work hard, but I'd like some say over when and where,' she says. Ben, the newest arrival, admits he was nervous at first. 'I'm comfortable with the software, but Margaret can look at a drawing and spot a problem in seconds. You can't download that kind of intuition.' To share such knowledge, the firm runs reverse mentoring alongside traditional schemes: younger staff help older colleagues with new tools, while experienced engineers pass on practical judgement.
Liam: Is that the secret of a good mixed-age team? Helen: It's one ingredient. The evidence suggests that age-diverse teams can make better decisions, because they combine different experiences and approaches, but only if people feel able to speak up. Without that, diversity can simply create friction. Managers should focus on individuals rather than categories: ask each person what helps them do their best work. Liam: And what about tension over things like working from home? Helen: Preferences on that vary enormously within every age group. It's usually more productive to agree clear team rules than to assume who will want what.
Back in Derby, Margaret is preparing to wind down to three days a week before she retires, and she is spending much of her time training Ben. 'I'll miss it,' she says. 'But it's nice to think that the things I've learnt will carry on.' Ben grins. 'She's tough, but she's the best teacher I've ever had. I just hope I'm half as patient when it's my turn.'